http://www.wsj.com/article_email/theranos-voids-two-years-of...
There is a reason Healthcare is regulated and required multiple degrees of testing before it can be released to the general public -- imagine every new "health startup" pushing new drugs and then saying they'll "fix a bug" when a couple of folks die. The comparison is immature.
Quite the opposite. Health regulations suffer from a number of perverse incentives that economists have studied extensively:
Drugs are needlessly delayed in getting to market. Doctors and patients are perfectly capable of assessing the risk/reward of an unproven treatment by looking at scientific studies. The FDA adds a layer of false-security... in spite of its sluggish process, the FDA is often quite wrong and drugs that were approved get taken off the market. For other drugs, they are delayed for several years and much harm is caused. Economists have studied this and found that regulators cause much needless suffering and death by being excessively risk-averse.
Consider too illegal drugs. Our regulators criminalize many substances, resulting in black market behavior and significant crime and other negative effects. Here too, backward regulations cause much unnecessary suffering, death (and crime too).
For people who do not understand healthcare, the world appears quite black and white. In reality no treatment works all of the time, and no test is without its share of inaccurate results. Doctors are equipped with enough Bayesian reasoning ability to use the available information wisely.
Also, a physician should not base any decisions on a single blood test result. That is not the proper way to use such tests. If it were, doctors and medical training would not be necessary. Most tests have a significant probability of false positive and false negative results, so docs are trained to consider the results only in the context of other diagnostic clues.
There's a line between not working perfectly and not working at all.
Yes, healthcare tech should at work at near perfect. There is an enormous difference between getting poor search results or not seeing photos of your drunk friend from the weekend and determining if you have a life-threatening illness. Healthcare is not an area where you want to be "bug testing" and the outcome can be life or death.
I agree that the tech should be explored and probably could be refined over time, but healthcare is an industry where you can't "fake it till you make it."
When you start to slide wildly of those bounds? That's when you get shut down. Where was Theranos?
Compare that to Theranos, where non-clinicians were deceiving customers with a tech that could not work in order to make money.
That kind of behaviour is rightly criticised.
Indeed it is. I think there is a big difference between a promising company whose technology has a few bugs and whose salespeople are overzealous and unethical, and a company that is an outright fraud.
See the problem?
Healthcare is one area where many people (particularly Americans) have the absurd idea that everything has to work perfectly.
Think of the level of indignation people feel when a surgeon who spent 15 years beyond college doing advanced training (for little pay) makes a small mistake that costs someone's life. Or an OB misjudges something and ends up in a major lawsuit.
But for other jobs, mistakes are a part of life. In software we are proud to decrease our bugs through testing and improved techniques and processes, but nobody expects perfection. Even mass market products like TurboTax ship with tons of bugs. Lawyers routinely let innocent people wind up in jail out of pure incompetence.
We need to get over it. Theranos is doing something very smart and while it needs some additional refinement, it is pretty clear that doing large scale blood testing/monitoring is the future of diagnostic medicine.
The irrationality we have about healthcare being perfect is a) false (mistakes get swept under the rug all the time) and b) counterproductive because it gives us a sense of mastery over our destiny that we simply do not (yet) have.
Let's also not forget that medicine is plagued by a very irrational risk aversion, which is why many useful treatments are available around the world but not in the US.