A successful petition tells the adjudicator the STORY of your rise to success. It's basically a narrated guide to the high-quality evidence you've provided in at least 3, preferably 4 or 5, categories: contributions, awards, media coverage, judging, authorship, etc.
The adjudication is subjective, but there's definitely a formula you can follow to maximize your chances of approval.
1. Continue seeking media coverage, the more prestigious the better.
2. Document the specific impacts your product has in making the world a better place. How has it made a dent in the universe? Factual evidence of specific, industry-wide impacts can really skyrocket your chances of success.
These impacts are hard for many applicants to explain and document, so if you can do it, it will really make your petition stand out.
3. Enter some competitions and win some awards (including, but not limited to, funding, admission to prestigious accelerators, etc.).
4. Judge some competitions or submissions: Hackathons, pitch competitions, applications for funding, peer review, anything in your industry.
5. Write and publish some articles, either on technical topics in your industry (better), or general-interest media articles and blog posts (good).
6. If you're making money, think about how to frame your compensation as higher than the norm in your industry. You have to prove, not only that you have high compensation, but that others similarly placed have lower compensation. There are a number of ways to present this, so it's good to start thinking about how to show a "pyramid."
HTH.
Interestingly, the O-1 and EB-11 categories don't consider US labor issues at all, the way that other categories do. For example, the number of US jobs you create isn't relevant, except as evidence of your success. Neither is the question of whether you're in a shortage occupation, or whether an American is available to fill the position.