Re:The wisdom of smaller crowds
by thaumasiotes on Friday June 24, 2016 @03:04PM
(#11972502)
Well, assuming a standard wisdom-of-the-crowds problem like "how much does that cow weigh?", the answer is drawn from a continuous interval and the probability of choosing the right answer is necessarily zero. Yet, the fact that that's a standard example of a wisdom-of-the-crowds problem suggests that the zero probability of being correct isn't really a big issue.
For a slightly different example like "how many jellybeans are there in this jar?", the answer is drawn from a discretized interval, but I feel pretty safe in assuming that the odds of any one crowd member getting it right are well below 50%.
Re:The wisdom of smaller crowds
by tedsanders on Friday June 24, 2016 @04:00PM
(#11972963)
No, that's incorrect in two ways. First, you must also assume that the individual opinions are independent. Second, the 0.5 probability threshold is only correct for binary situations; in real life where they may be a range of opinions, the threshold is much lower.
> Second, the 0.5 probability threshold is only correct for binary situations; in real life where they may be a range of opinions, the threshold is much lower.
The study from the article did focus on binary situations. From the article:
> Where previous research on collective intelligence deals mainly with decisions of ‘how much’ or ‘how many,’ the current study applies to ‘this or that’ decisions under a majority vote.
Perhaps having a smaller size allows the "noise" in the group to still produce the "right" answer more often than it would in a larger group?