First off, if you patented it, and I can see a lot of value from licensing the idea, then yes, I will pay a lot for it.
Second, I don't get why people are so focused on valuing an idea in-and-of-itself. Just because when some Joe says "I have a great idea" we don't attach any monetary value to that, doesn't mean that "ideas are useless".
It's like if some Joe says "I'm great at executing". Nobody will pay him for that. That has no monetary value. But that doesn't mean that "execution is useless".
It's the combination of idea+execution that has monetary value.
If specific ideas are to have specific value, there must be a common method of differentiation. How do you tell the difference between a high quality idea and a terrible one?
Finally, if ideas have so much value, how come the market has basically been against the "idea guy", and almost entirely values execution (success = traction, revenue)?
I'm Paul Graham, and I've got a fantastic, knock-your-socks-off idea for a business. How much will you pay me for it?
OR
I'm Travis. I've got a mediocre idea, but have spent a lot of time learning about my customers and market. I've built a kickass piece of software that solves the pain. But, again, my idea isn't that great (think Craigslist: the idea of online classifieds isn't exactly a great one, or a novel/clever one...) Will you pay me more for this?