News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft vs the Karate Kid by rbanffy on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @05:30PM (#1196878)
Eventually Microsoft will be able to produce something as good as a current iPod. Unfortunately for them, by that time, it's quite likely Apple will have raised the bar once again with another gizmo.

It's also possible Microsoft will leave the copycat behaviour behind and start creating original products instead of knock-offs of the market leaders. That, however, seems unlikely.

I can't remember a Microsoft product that was genuinely pioneering something.

Re:Microsoft vs the Karate Kid by swernli on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @09:14PM (#1197381)
I'd call Xbox Live a successful, innovative product, especially given the way they've continued to evolve it in a way that delivers more value to the user and gradually gets them closer to the idea of having the Xbox as the center of the entertainment system.

Personally, despite not owning one myself, I'd say that the Zune HD is already on par with the iPod Touch in terms of what the product offers. They have different strengths, overlapp in some areas, and both make excellent devices. The iPod Touch wins only when you include the content of the App Store (note that I'm making a distinction between the Store and the content there). If Windows Phone lives up to what they've shown so far, I believe that landscape may shift toward parity faster than you'd expect...

Re:Microsoft vs the Karate Kid by rbanffy on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @10:39PM (#1197556)
> I'd call Xbox Live a successful, innovative product

How, exactly? Evolving a product is neither revolutionary nor particularly original. A multi-player hub? An app-store? I am pretty much sure everything on this list was invented by someone else. XBL is a successful product, but it's the execution, not being first.

Also, having the whole Xbox user population captive doesn't hurt market share. It's not like they could go to the Playstation hub.

> Zune HD is already on par with the iPod Touch in terms of what the product offers

Also, it's not feature count, it's how well it works on the whole. The iPod was never the feature-count leader - just about every competitor had more features or could perform some tricks the iPods of that time couldn't. It's how well rounded the product is. The iPod is a solid product and was the first really usable music player. It works really well. Besides that, a Zune HD won't work with a Mac, despite the fact iPods work very well with PCs (and, with some fiddling, other Unixes).

I don't always like Apple (their DRM'ed cables are ridiculous and OSX is Unix with a 70's feel when you drop into the terminal) but I have to admit they do some really excellent products my family can use.

Re:Microsoft vs the Karate Kid by swernli on Wednesday March 17, 2010 @12:53AM (#1197817)
> Evolving a product is neither revolutionary nor particularly original.

Interesting, because the example you point to, the iPod, didn't really capture it's outrageously huge market share until the iPod Mini, which was an evolution on the original design. In fact, the entire iPod line until the introduction of touch was a steady evolution from one to the next, and continued onward winning over customers. It beat out other mp3 players despite all of them having the same features, if not more, by doing it well. Or as you put it:

>I am pretty much sure everything on this list was invented by someone else ... it's the execution, not being first ... Also, it's not feature count, it's how well it works on the whole.

Thanks for making my point for me :)

Re:Microsoft vs the Karate Kid by bigbang on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @06:48PM (#1197031)
"I can't remember a Microsoft product that was genuinely pioneering something."

Surface and Natal comes to my mind. But then again, I've seen both only in videos.

Re:Microsoft vs the Karate Kid by rbanffy on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @06:59PM (#1197057)
Natal is not a product yet. It has been demoed in controlled scenarios and it has been announced that it will hit the market by the end of this year. Wanna bet it won't?

Surface appears heavily inspired by Jeff Han's TED presentation or a Reactable (I am sure both came first). Calling it a shipping product is somewhat of a stretch. It's more like a tech demonstrator you can buy, if they are willing to sell you one and you are willing to pay what they want for it.

Call me skeptical, but I am only counting products that you can buy at a computer store or download or use through the web.