News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by laumars on Friday June 24, 2016 @06:33AM (#11968559)
I did ponder over this myself in recent weeks. I wondered whether there should be a age limit on votes, whether votes should be weighted, and even wondered whether there should be a quick multiple choice test that you have to pass before voting. Unfortunately the first two points go against the point of democracy - even if it might feel unfair to those are the greatest impacted by large demographics of people who are least affected but have strong opinions.

The entrance exam idea is a little more complex though. The idea came about because I was frustrated by the number of people I'd spoken to who voted for a particular campaign while admitting they didn't really follow the campaign but just wanted "change". I saw it with a lot of UKIP supporters who hadn't read their manifesto. I also saw it with the EU referendum with friends that were unaware of any of the "Brexit" arguments but voted out anyway. I think it's weird - in fact borderline dangerous - to use ones vote to decide on a topic which one has intentionally chosen not to educate one's self on. However how do you test that one is informed without biasing the ballot? I think that could be an impossible challenge - and even if it was possible, it would be too easy to abuse at some point further down the line. So that eliminates that possibility as well.

Giving everyone an equal vote is the fundamental principle of democracy. And as much as we might complain about biases from specific demographics skewing the outcome, be that the older generation, younger generation, politically literate, racist, socialist, or whatever; we just have to live with the results. After all, as much as I might disagree with some agendas, there's others I agree with which I'm sure other demographics detest on principles that are as reasoned as the arguments I consider to be true. Such is the nature of individuals.

Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by WalterBright on Friday June 24, 2016 @06:46AM (#11968633)
A good system would be based on the idea that everyone I don't agree with is not allowed to vote.
Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by executesorder66 on Friday June 24, 2016 @06:43AM (#11968614)
I like your idea of a test before hand.

Every voter is required to write a test on the matter being voted on. And then their vote is weighted on the marks they got for the test.

That way people who have no idea what they are voting for have little say in the matter. And the people who really care about the issues will make sure they know how their vote will affect things, and they get a greater say in the matter.

Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by MichaelGG on Friday June 24, 2016 @06:56AM (#11968695)
And how do you grade the test? Certainly if there was objective criteria for what would happen in this case (In/Out), there'd be no need for a vote at all!

On top of that, why shouldn't someone be able to vote on the basis of purely not wanting to be in the EU? Or voting with someone based on their perceived moral value? Or any other criteria?

I'm hardly pro-democracy, but this doesn't seem like a democratic solution.

Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by executesorder66 on Friday June 24, 2016 @07:11AM (#11968778)
> And how do you grade the test? Certainly if there was objective criteria...

It would have to be on whatever objective facts are available. But in situations like this that could be rather difficult.

> on the basis of purely not wanting to be in the EU?

IMHO making big decisions based purely on your feelings is always a bad idea.

> but this doesn't seem like a democratic solution

It's not democratic at all. But I'm just throwing around ideas for interest's sake. Until a provably better system comes around, I'd choose to live in a democratic country.

Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by corobo on Friday June 24, 2016 @08:25AM (#11969191)
> Every voter is required to write a test on the matter being voted on

Meaning less people would show up to vote due to the time/effort.

Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by mac01021 on Friday June 24, 2016 @10:54AM (#11970219)
That sounds ok to me.
Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by corobo on Friday June 24, 2016 @11:09AM (#11970338)
When you say things like that on less-jokey forums such as this one you look sillier than the people you're trying to mock. Just a heads up.
Re:Young voters wanted Brexit the least – and will have to l... by mac01021 on Friday June 24, 2016 @12:37PM (#11971193)
I'm not mocking you - just disagreeing with one of your premises.

While I doubt anyone will ever produce a concrete proposal for a testing system that is not too problematic for me to support it, I am not dismayed in the least by the prospect of losing voters who are not willing to invest the mental energy required by a 20-minute test on the topic of the vote.

You seem to assume that a reduction in voter turnout is unconditionally bad. I disagree.