News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lenin was a mushroom by tgb on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @12:54PM (#11955319)
I can say with confidence that you're wrong about a point on a non-skidding wheel moving backwards. I can't read your book though, it says that the page is unavailable.

Consider the wheel in the frame of the train. The train moves at velocity v relative to the ground. So the bottom of the wheel moves with velocity v backwards in the frame of the train. The top moves velocity v forward in that frame. All other points move at the same speed but in directions that aren't perfectly horizontal so move at a slower horizontal speed. But for a point to move backwards relative to the ground it must move at a horizontal speed greater than v in the frame of the train. So there is no such point.

Re:Lenin was a mushroom by lotyrin on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @04:22PM (#11956680)
I haven't read this either, but the flange(?) of the wheel, the part below/behind the rail, is on the same lever as the point where the wheel contacts the rail (v), but further from the axis, so it's moving further (>v), also opposite the direction of the train's forward motion, so total negative speed, in the frame of the rail/ground.

This is why a train is picked over most vehicles, which operate as you describe.

Re:Lenin was a mushroom by tgb on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @05:19PM (#11957105)
Yes, you're totally right, my analysis applies to bikes not trains!

A tale in over-confidence / Google book previews availability.