Re:More awful IoT stuff
by kbenson on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @12:04PM
(#11954940)
Well, there's no point in waiting around for a company to make a local service their device connects to for us, since the incentive is not to deliver what we would really get the most use out of, but to deliver something that maximizes their revenue, likely though only accepting other devices of the same company, or those that have licensed access in some way. If we make a system that can be interacted with, we'll get some cheap cheap manufacturers that use it because they'll try anything, and if it catches, either we'll have a good system, or more likely, manufacturers will band together to create their own standard that's technically not as good but more likely to be supported widely.
I imagine something like the following would be good:
- Each component runs in it's own chroot/container/virt so the manufacturer can provide whatever they want, and the user can throttle it if it's poorly engineered.
- Discovery service that allows installed network server components to register with it for discovery. (Sun's RPC service, anyone?)
- Possibly also to proxy all traffic through discovery service, so network components have to specifically register for direct network access with very specific access limits if they want to use an internet service or talk to a company server.
- Separate file systems exposed for the application and stored data for each app, so a memory card card can be used for the data portion, and replacing hardware is fairly simple (after base software is installed, each application will discover it's configuration and stored data from the provided memory card). Possibly even a separation between data and config as well. IP cameras can spool all their recorded video to the data partition, which might be a large attached disk, but their config can be on a separate, easily swapped memory card, for maximum choice when upgrading.
- Let the manufacturers work out standardizing protocols for their industry, or not, and integrating with other apps, but let apps see the list of available apps, and request access to other ones, so devices from the same manufacturer or ones with a partnership can leverage each other.
- Lots of other stuff people will come up with along the way.
I imagine you could get any relatively cheap box, install the base software (linux distro of choice plus framework, or distro dedicated to this), and have it mostly work. Something like FreeNAS and similar projects.
Does anyone know of any groups out there working on something like this? Maybe some docker oriented distro that aims to be super simple comes closest?
I imagine something like the following would be good:
- Each component runs in it's own chroot/container/virt so the manufacturer can provide whatever they want, and the user can throttle it if it's poorly engineered.
- Discovery service that allows installed network server components to register with it for discovery. (Sun's RPC service, anyone?)
- Possibly also to proxy all traffic through discovery service, so network components have to specifically register for direct network access with very specific access limits if they want to use an internet service or talk to a company server.
- Separate file systems exposed for the application and stored data for each app, so a memory card card can be used for the data portion, and replacing hardware is fairly simple (after base software is installed, each application will discover it's configuration and stored data from the provided memory card). Possibly even a separation between data and config as well. IP cameras can spool all their recorded video to the data partition, which might be a large attached disk, but their config can be on a separate, easily swapped memory card, for maximum choice when upgrading.
- Let the manufacturers work out standardizing protocols for their industry, or not, and integrating with other apps, but let apps see the list of available apps, and request access to other ones, so devices from the same manufacturer or ones with a partnership can leverage each other.
- Lots of other stuff people will come up with along the way.
I imagine you could get any relatively cheap box, install the base software (linux distro of choice plus framework, or distro dedicated to this), and have it mostly work. Something like FreeNAS and similar projects.
Does anyone know of any groups out there working on something like this? Maybe some docker oriented distro that aims to be super simple comes closest?
Edit: Added another point or two.