News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Writing my first interpreter in C for fun by sklogic on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @06:10AM (#11952652)
> it tends to be much easier to provide good error messages with a recursive-descent parser

It is not any more complicated with a parser generator (if it's a PEG-based one). In fact, it's much easier, you're avoiding a lot of boilerplate this way.

> There's also something to be said for not having a dependency on an extra tool

Do not have a dependency on an extra tool. Use a meta-language, in which a parser generator can be embedded as a first class language feature.

Re:Show HN: Writing my first interpreter in C for fun by groovy2shoes on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @02:52PM (#11996429)
> It is not any more complicated with a parser generator (if it's a PEG-based one). In fact, it's much easier, you're avoiding a lot of boilerplate this way.

True. PEGs are effing great!

> Do not have a dependency on an extra tool. Use a meta-language, in which a parser generator can be embedded as a first class language feature.

This is ideal, but unfortunately not always possible. For example, if you're stuck writing a language processor in C, you don't get the necessary tools for linguistic abstraction without an external dependency. In general, though, I agree with the sentiment.