There are some complications to consider. Maybe a 3rd company can pay drivers a little less because it treats them more nicely than Uber does, or maybe riders will be willing to pay more or wait more for a 3rd company's cars for some reason (e.g. Lyft's tends to be friendlier while Uber is more formal, and some users are willing to pay more for the former). But in general the more passengers and drivers an app has, the better off both sides of that app's market will be.
Or the tech benefit of actively working people in Uber will be much better ROI for drivers to give a 20% cut -- which other industry gives such high a cut? (airlines or movie ticket booking doesnt)
Uber and Lyft provide a substantial amount of infrastructure and staffing; they wouldn't function without that. Someone has to keep the server infrastructure running and scaling, and even more importantly, someone has to maintain the support, rating, and qualification system to maintain quality.
I've seen many drivers running both lyft and uber at the same time. A third company comes along that pays drivers better? Why not keep all three apps up. There's no cost to running an additional app. Literally none at all. And if it pays slightly better, or has a fairer reputation system...
The same thing works on the rider side as well. If you've got an app (like what's the fair) that can let you query any number of providers and get the cheapest price, maybe you're happy to wait a few minutes to save money.