Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by dkarapetyan on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:38PM
(#11942930)
This doesn't sound right to me. Contract law should not require turing completeness. First order logic should be more than sufficient. How does having a loop in contract law make any sense?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There are also a class of total languages (Coq, Agda, Idris) that are guaranteed to terminate but admit (polymorphic) recursion. This is stronger than FOL but weaker than turing-completeness, and certainly sufficient to implement any feasible contract.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by dkarapetyan on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @12:57AM
(#11943598)
I agree. I said first-order logic because I think it is more accessible. Coq, Agda, Idris, etc. employ I think some pretty sophisticated type theory and that would all have to be packaged up in a way that is accessible to an average programmer.
> in a way that is accessible to an average programmer.
The average programmer should not be writing multi-million-dollar contracts.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by Paradigma11 on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @07:45AM
(#11944987)
But : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solidity "As specified by Wood it is designed around the ECMAScript syntax to make it familiar for existing web developers;"
Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by dkarapetyan on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @01:07AM
(#11943627)
I don't think accessibility is a bad thing. I think computing, its practice and theory, should be taught the same way we teach literacy. I didn't mean "average" as in "incompetent". If writing contracts was as simple as writing a few lines of code in some formal language that didn't require a law or finance degree then I would consider that to be a good thing. It would be even better if the system was designed from first principles with solid theory backing it.
I totally agree, but the reality is that in order to write contracts that are sure to be correct, you need a level of expertise that involves much more work than just learning how to write programs. Knowing the syntax and usage of a rigorously-typed language like Agda is the easy part.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by kowdermeister on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @05:36AM
(#11944577)
Then the platform is flawed. Average programmers should be able to understand it easily.
It's not that hard, some wants X and some wants Y in exchange.
I'm not a lawyer but I write contracts with my clients. If you keep things simple it should fit most people. making g smart contracts complicated you keep it in the area of a small elite who are knowledgeable of playing safe with it.
I wold go as far as make it as simple as HTML.
That's what standardized contracts are for. Tellers don't write the legalese on your credit card receipt. They just print it out.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by plaguuuuuu on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @01:49AM
(#11943744)
I agree. Furthermore, the notion of contracts that cannot be specified in first-order logic seems relatively dangerous to me.
Could you expand on how one would specify DAO-like contracts with only first-order logic?
Re:Ethereum is Doomed
by conception on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @12:39AM
(#11943535)
Would regular payments based on criteria be an example? A paycheck basically.
This argues for a temporal logic, not for recursion. Something like: http://szabo.best.vwh.net/contractlanguage.html