News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An open letter to Netflix from the authors of the de-anon... by nkurz on Monday March 15, 2010 @02:43PM (#1193716)
Ironically (and I think this is a legitimate use of the term) I hadn't realized when writing my comment that 'randomwalker' and 'Arvind Narayanan' were one and the same. But I apologize for my misinterpretation. I've read it again, though, and still have to fight the same reaction. Perhaps I'm just prejudiced against the 'open letter' format, as I often see it used in that way.

Still, if you can overlook my misreading, I would love your response. I understand that the example from the FAQ is not central to your argument, but I do think it's important in understanding your worldview. If I provide a tool that can be used, erroneously or not, to create or enable prejudice, at what point have I crossed the line into 'violation of privacy'?

Re:An open letter to Netflix from the authors of the de-anon... by randomwalker on Monday March 15, 2010 @05:46PM (#1194225)
I responded to most of the points in a new top-level comment. As for whether there is a violation of privacy even if the conclusions are erroneous, no, I don't think that it is. Some of my colleagues argue that it is, but I don't agree with that point of view. In other words, in order to convince you that there is a privacy problem I have to convince you of the math in the paper. Merely the fact that we came up with an algorithm that may or may not be correct is not sufficient.

That FAQ question is a big red herring. Some of the objections to our paper during peer-review were along the lines of "if Netflix had esentially duplicated every record in the database, how could you be sure you found the right record? What does right record even mean?" No really, it was that silly. So it was meant to be a way to justify the fact that de-anonymization can happen even if you didn't find "the right record."