News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by gaius on Monday March 15, 2010 @01:31PM (#1193485)
OK, but that's not relevant. You know why Outlook is vulnerable? Because it's openly scriptable. If you can convince someone to run your script, they can do whatever they like, so name it AnnaKournikovaNekkid.exe and many, many people were convinced. And that's the key: an open device in the hands of someone who doesn't thoroughly understand it merely creates problems for those that do.
Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by nzmsv on Monday March 15, 2010 @03:02PM (#1193777)
Executables aren't scripts. Outlook is not open.

The problem Outlook had a few years ago was exactly the opposite. A completely closed system, set up with insecure settings by default. It would run the scripts inside an email when you viewed it, and did not require the user to click on anything. The idea was to make things easier for the user. How's that for ironic? :)

Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by cschneid on Monday March 15, 2010 @03:31PM (#1193843)
But Windows is open, and that virus .exe runs with no "authorization" from Microsoft. Your argument of insecure by default is a red-herring in the current discussion.

So you have to be defensive in your use of more open systems, because anybody could have written malicious code for you, and you're lacking the walls of the walled garden to protect you.

As I've been stating through the thread, I am taking this stance because I want to be lazy and safe when using my phone. I don't need or want another full-blown computer to take care of, update, and defend. The trick will be getting the right "jailbreak" switch that's easy for technical people to flip, but very difficult for lay-people to get tricked into.

Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by dminor on Monday March 15, 2010 @11:49PM (#1194900)
Does Apple do a complete code review of every app they approve? Your walled garden isn't protecting you from anything.
Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by cschneid on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @01:00AM (#1195056)
Of course you're right. They couldn't have done full code reviews on every app. But they do review every app to some degree. Combine that with the locked-down nature of the phone, and you get a reasonable amount of security.
Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by SwellJoe on Tuesday March 16, 2010 @01:56PM (#1196353)
You know why Outlook is vulnerable? Because it's openly scriptable. If you can convince someone to run your script, they can do whatever they like, so name it AnnaKournikovaNekkid.exe and many, many people were convinced.

That's possibly the stupidest argument I've heard all day.

Outlook is nowhere near open. Popular open source mail clients have a much better security record than Outlook. Security failings of Microsoft are a ridiculous way to argue against openness.

Re: Now A No-Evil Zone by gaius on Friday March 19, 2010 @05:01PM (#1205270)
With Outlook, with a few lines of VBscript, you can iterate over the addressbook, for example. With Pine, you, umm, can't. Outlook is vulnerable because it exposes features that can be easily abused. Pine isn't because it does less.

Now if you are a corporate software developer and you want to build some sort of workflow application (remember this is in the days before the web was ubiquitous) you could very easily do it with just Outlook and Exchange, which you had. Chances are someone in your department could do it, you wouldn't even need to involve your IT department.

Microsoft were naive to think that the features they included wouldn't be abused, I'm not excusing them there. Of course software can be more secure if it does less. Like the very best firewall is the AirGap(tm).