News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by Animats on Sunday June 19, 2016 @02:21PM (#11933957)
Well, this is a mess. Remember, there's a clock ticking - there are, what, 25 more days before the funds from the first exploit become liquid. With more exploits being found, the original proposed patch, which just blocks a specific destination address, won't work.

The price of Etherium has fallen about 35% since this started. The Etherium market cap has dropped from $1.5bn to under $1bn. Volume hit an all time high, and the price is still in a screaming dive as people try to get out.[1]

I wouldn't be surprised if the person behind the exploit turns out to be an insider. That would be in keeping with cryptocurrency tradition. In the Bitcoin world, most of the major "hacks" turned out to be insider theft.

[1] http://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/ethereum/

Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by cjbprime on Sunday June 19, 2016 @03:43PM (#11934350)
The patch does not block a destination address; it blocks all transfers from the DAO's source address, as a stopgap towards better solutions.

(It actually works on all instances of the DAO's code address, not just the famous ~$150M instance.)

https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/pull/2715

> There's simply the notion of --illegal-code-hashes that takes a list of hashes that are placed in "ignore-mode".

Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by vegabook on Sunday June 19, 2016 @04:54PM (#11934627)
I am not convinced that this is actually theft. The "exploit" was simply code. And code rules, in the "The DAO"/ethereum world.

Indeed, isn't it arguable that said insider(s) (and I agree it's probably an inseder) should identify themselves and challenge the leadership who are damaging their own credibility and that of ethereum generally? All these rollbacks -> they are the ones which are arguably illegal as they override the code. In my view, the so-called thieves have a legitimate claim on the ETH they have made and the investors in the DAO should respect the old caveat-emptor idea which is axiomatic to all investments, both inside and outside the blockchain world. They invested in a dog, and they should lose all their money. This is efficient markets at work.

Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by jsmeaton on Sunday June 19, 2016 @05:30PM (#11934775)
It's more like they invested in a VC firm which then siphoned off all the money into a Swiss account. You'd have recourse through the court system.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by vegabook on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:01PM (#11934911)
no, because the VC is ruled by law, and The DAO was ruled only by code, even if it contained exploits. As such the rules of the code - the law of The DAO - were followed.

The correct analogy is that the exploiters shorted the investment after performing thorough due diligence, and made a profit doing so, at the expense of more ignorant investors. That those more ignorant investors included the founders of ethereum and the authors of the code, is deliciously ironic especially considering (perhaps even because of) their own self-importance[1], but it is ultimately immaterial.

[1] https://daohub.org/curator.html

Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by kahnpro on Monday June 20, 2016 @12:32AM (#11936064)
The DAO, ultimately, is a human construct and subject to human laws. Just because you write a something in code and do a bit of hand waving, it doesn't mean that contract law, etc, magically ceases to exist.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by vegabook on Monday June 20, 2016 @03:50AM (#11936671)
it is ironic that The DAO will then rely on something which they were trying to supplant.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by antisthenes on Monday June 20, 2016 @01:30PM (#11939550)
Yes, an irony most likely lost on the libertarian populace.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by johnzim on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @06:01AM (#11944668)
Think you might have Libertarian and Anarchist conflated there.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by tamana on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:34PM (#11935042)
Everything is ruled by law, unless you are stateless. In USA, it is legally impossible for some one with net worth under a $1million to sign away protections by claiming due diligence.
Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by vegabook on Sunday June 19, 2016 @07:20PM (#11935221)
question: say it is ascertained that 80% of the value of the DAO was tightly held by a small number of people all worth > 1m USD, then have those people signed away their due diligence through the explicit primacy of the code as per the DAO's terms?

question 2: those worth less than 1m USD -> who do they sue? The "thieves" who were acting according to the terms and conditions? Or the DAO itself?

Re:Another successful DAO attack recursive split by tamana on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:29PM (#11935023)
Why insider ? Ethereum/TheDAO posted an ad that said "$40M investment award to anyone who can find an exploitable bug in our open-source contract software" , which would affect many a competent outsider.