News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by kevindeasis on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:08AM (#11932434)
It's interesting to imagine what Djikstra would've accomplished if he instead decided to focus on theoretical physics. Conversely, imagine what we would've lost if we didn't have Djikstra as a programmer.

I'd like to point out that Dijkstra's writing might arguably the best writing I've seen from a programmer. English is not my first language and his writing is inspiring; if possible I'd like to request if anyone can point me to a resource (apps, software, etc) so I can learn to write, speak, and converse like Dijkstra in this lecture?

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by gizmo on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:18AM (#11933036)
Dijkstra writes directly and with and air of authority, but his writing is not great. His style is pretentious and obfuscatory. Even worse, he uses his authoritative style to get away with tons of unsubstantiated assertions. Let's look at a passage from the linked lecture:

Those who want really reliable software will discover [authority!] that they must find means of avoiding the majority of bugs to start with [unsubstantiated!], and as a result the programming process will become cheaper [unsubstantiated!]. If you want more effective programmers, you will discover [authority!] that they should not waste their time debugging [repeated assertion!], they should not introduce the bugs to start with [repeated assertion!].

He could just say:

When creating reliable software debugging takes up much time. If we develop techniques that prevent these bugs from being introduced in the first place then programmers will become much more effective.

Good writing is terse and easy to understand. It should lead the reader from the premises to the conclusions. Good writing shouldn't contain pretentious detours. I don't think you should emulate Dijkstra.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by tel on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:45AM (#11933130)
I doubt Djikstra would have been Djikstra is he communicated in such a sterile way. His writing achieved the ends he sought. He's memorable and endlessly quoted which gives life to his ideas beyond what is immediately provable.

You might argue this is improper, but I think that's a bit morose. I dread the day when all people write like that second sentence.

That's not to say someone should emulate him, though. It's not that it's wrong, it's that they're bound to fail and produce something tinny and derivative. That's the thing your revised sentence has going for it: it's as cheap as it is limp.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by gizmo on Sunday June 19, 2016 @11:31AM (#11933284)
That's the thing with blowhards. When you take away their rhetoric and literary flourishes they've got nothing left.

If something becomes boring and derivative when stated plainly then there was nothing of substance to start with.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by steveklabnik on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:12PM (#11933434)

  > Good writing is terse and easy to understand. 
Good writing does what it sets out to do. "terse and easy to understand" is a fantastic style for certain objectives, but there's no one "good writing" style.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by shrugger on Sunday June 19, 2016 @01:29PM (#11933750)
And you say you don't like Ayn Rand! Terse is just another word for unimaginative, when it comes to prose.

I think you might be blurring the lines between writing something in a socratic dialogue versus writing technical documentation. Dijkstra, obviously often is writing in the former style and so there's plenty of room for his personality in the text and it doesn't take away from the overall quality and cohesiveness of the text.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by steveklabnik on Sunday June 19, 2016 @02:05PM (#11933883)
I don't think I'm blurring; if anything, I'm sharpening! Not all text is the same, and it's important to know what you're trying to accomplish when you set out to write something.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by gizmo on Sunday June 19, 2016 @02:49PM (#11934088)
Hemmingway has a terse writing style, but few consider his prose unimaginative.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by Bromskloss on Sunday June 19, 2016 @11:45AM (#11933338)
Not that I dislike your version, but aren't the claims as unsubstantiated there as they are in the original? (And I don't know how they could be anything else when someone is simply sharing their informally gained insights.)
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by gizmo on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:04PM (#11933400)
Oh, you're right. I didn't introduce new arguments because I only wanted to change the delivery of what Dijkstra wrote and not the substance.

I also don't mind unsubstantiated claims. It's just obnoxious to phrase it like "any person with half a brain knows [controversial claim]".

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by seanwilson on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:46PM (#11933564)
> Dijkstra writes directly and with and air of authority, but his writing is not great. His style is pretentious and obfuscatory. Even worse, he uses his authoritative style to get away with tons of unsubstantiated assertions.

This bugs me as well. He's obviously made profound and exceptional contributions to the field but I don't like when he writes in the manner you pointed out where he's making bold statements without evidence. Worse is when people quote something Dijkstra wrote that he didn't back up with evidence as if it's true just because Dijkstra wrote it.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by RobGR on Sunday June 19, 2016 @01:20PM (#11933717)
But, if Dijsktra wrote it, it is right, where as if seanwilson wrote it and cited 100 papers in Datamation it might still be wrong.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by kevindeasis on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:54AM (#11933162)
Thanks! Your statement gives me good insight and I find it helpful, and it seems to complement @jonahx's comments.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by jwdunne on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:08AM (#11932697)
Similar to the baseline advice to learn programming: write a lot. Read good writing, read bad writing and learn to tell the difference. Leaving a piece of writing for 24 hours and coming back to it with a fresh pair of eyes to edit helps. Someone else's eyes also helps, similar to how code reviews help.

Reciting your writing out loud helps too. If it isn't in the desired tone and/or it doesn't sound natural, rewrite it. You may find you need less adverbs than you think.

Books on writing style and techniques help in the way books about algorithms, paradigms, design patterns and other facets of programming help. The key is to implement the ideas you learn in your writing.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by hga on Sunday June 19, 2016 @07:32AM (#11932618)
I suppose, but unless he felt a true calling to become a theoretical physicist, as is partly outlined in this piece, his decision was clearly right, for the previous golden age of physics was well over by late '50s, and progress since then has been minimal compared to the Thirty Years that Shook Physics (quantum theory: https://www.amazon.com/Thirty-Years-that-Shook-Physics/dp/04...), General Relatively (still our best theory of gravity), and the revelations of the secrets of the nucleus. Maybe also Feynman and company's development of the first quantum field theory.

There were of course a lot of things of smaller scope to be done, and the unification of EM and the weak nuclear force was in the future, as well as the imperfect Standard Model that adds the strong nuclear force, and we still haven't unified gravity and the other three fundamental forces, but programming was wide open, and what you could do was rapidly improving as the machines were rapidly becoming faster and bigger. ADDED: For example, the Electrologica X1 he did his Ph.D. thesis on was solid state, as in completely transistorized (no vacuum tubes) and had magnetic core memory, both major advances in the '50s.

Heck, my calling was science, and I was strongly on that track as of 1968, but computers nonetheless gained a lot of my attention starting in the mid-late '70s, as they did for Feynman starting with the Manhattan Project when "computers" were the operators of 10 digit electromechanical scientific calculators.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by jonahx on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:16AM (#11933026)
If you want to write specifically like that, read Bronte, Austen, and other 19th century authors. It's a more verbose, grammatically complex style of prose that's not in vogue anymore. When it's done well, I personally enjoy it, but if your aspiration is to emulate that style you should be warned that to the ear of most modern English speakers it rings overly formal, if not pompous.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by kevindeasis on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:57AM (#11933176)
Thanks, what you've said resonates well after @gizmo's second paragraph.
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by stdbrouw on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:20AM (#11932461)
> if possible I'd like to request if anyone can point me to a resource (apps, software, etc) so I can learn to write, speak, and converse like Dijkstra in this lecture?

Practice makes perfect, that's really all there is to it. A good book on writing style can help, but only if you use it. The Sense of Style by Steven Pinker and Revising Prose by Richard Lanham are my two favorites.

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by kevindeasis on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:36AM (#11932498)
Thanks! I'll start checking out the book
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by f_allwein on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:59AM (#11932541)
For writing, The Elements of Style by Strunk/ White is a classic I still found useful. Plus, as has been said, read a lot of good prose.

Similarly for public speaking, practice makes perfect. Check out Toastmasters International - a nonprofit that is running clubs all over the world where members can improve their public speaking skills in a supportive environment. Worked for me.

http://www.toastmasters.org

Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by kevindeasis on Sunday June 19, 2016 @07:04AM (#11932550)
Fascinating, I wasn't even aware there were lots of toastmaster clubs in my city. Thanks for the heads up, I'll check them out!
Re:E.W. Dijkstra Archive: The Humble Programmer by f_allwein on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:45AM (#11932780)
Yes, they're a bit of an open secret in that many people who would love them never even hear about them.