Giving a full length run down of my decision making process just opens the door for a conversation that I don't want to have, and isn't going to make anyone happy.
Now, if I can reject someone as a candidate for the position of my wife after four dates without a long discussion, then why can't I reject someone for the position of engineer after zero ?
First, that "unreliable online material" is likely a social networking site and can be tied to the person in question with a high degree of reliability. This is certainly not perfect, mistaken identity is always possible, as is impersonation, but on social networking sites you can normally say it is more likely than not the right person. I am not saying that it is right to make judgements on someone's employability based on those sites, just that you can often be pretty confident you are talking about the right person.
Next, the rational for rejecting an applicant is very frequently "We found a better candidate." Now, the reason they judged that other candidate to be better might be because they found something they didn't like about applicant A on the internet, but that is still often going to be the rationale.