News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Lessons Learned from Y Combinator Rejection by coffeemug on Monday March 15, 2010 @06:24AM (#1192614)
At the very least, YC partners are trying a novel experiment nobody has tried before, and if you're a curious person, it's interesting where it will go. If it succeeds, great! If it fails, at least it's a really interesting thing to try, and it inspired hundreds (thousands?) of people to strive to do great things.

I honestly want to know, what compels you to knock smart, energetic people trying new, interesting things? Even if the idea is ridiculous, who could it possibly hurt?

Re:Tell HN: Lessons Learned from Y Combinator Rejection by gizmo on Monday March 15, 2010 @07:04AM (#1192673)
[devil's advocate]

YC could end up hurting all the founders. YC is selling a message that it's OK not to worry about a business model or revenue (or profit!), and that may turn out to be horrendous advice. In this case YC is partly responsible for the creation of a new web 2.0 no-revenue-required bubble.

So what you call "knocking smart energetic people" may just be a highly needed reality check, to keep people from dropping out of college and investing their savings and future into doomed ventures.

[/devil's advocate]

Re:Tell HN: Lessons Learned from Y Combinator Rejection by p6 on Monday March 15, 2010 @09:28AM (#1192854)
Thank you for referring to me as the devil. Thats quite a compliment.