I dare anyone to write a scientific paper or book using Markdown. In Asciidoc it's doable. And before you say that a markup language is the wrong tool for the job, let me remind you that nowadays authors might want to produce different formats (HTML, ePub, text-only) from the same source file which is difficult with LaTeX.
I wish I had time to evaluate them in more detail, but so far I've stayed with LaTeX, which I feel is not the right tool for the job for material that's not going to be printed on paper.
I would never try to write a book in Markdown, no matter how extended; but considering the HTML produced by asciidoc|tor, you might also say "don't use AsciiDoc for simple Web publishing."
What I find much more fascinating is the question why there is no good general-purpose format that works equally well for blogging and for scientific papers and for books?
Is it really that hard a problem?
AsciiDoc has some very newbie-hostile quirks, at least as of now it more or less requires asciidoctor, and even then its output HTML is terrible. Terrible as in Wrong, as in...
In fact, since I have not yet found an asciidoc converter that produces decent HTML, and I don't have time to write one, I may yet fall back into the "everything sorta supports Markdown" trap.