News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by zaidf on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:04PM (#119210)
Scribd takes that into account by stating PDF "sometimes" requires download. I think that is fair--most marketers would just say "yes" instead of "sometimes."

Also, it wouldn't be a stretch to assume the penetration of Flash as greater than Acrobat Reader.

"This is not a tool for generating documents, its a tool for viewing/embedding them."

Let's back up to the original goal of PDF: fixed-layout document sharing with built-in security. To generate PDF files, Adobe SELLS Acrobat to general PDF files.

iPaper seems to be a) implementing the original goal of PDF, b) with better usability, and c) with no cost to convert.

Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by tolmasky on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:19PM (#119226)
How are they beating PDF on cost? Acrobat Reader is free, and they don't put ads in there.

On top of that, they say that the cost of creating documents is "free". What? Are they handing out free Word licenses with this thing or something? Because last time I checked, the price of creating a document for iPaper is the cost of the program that makes the original document for iPaper. As you stated yourself, "converting" to iPaper is free. So yeah, if all your documents are TXT files then this thing is free, but if you want any semblance of structure in your document then you're probably using... you guessed it, DOC or PDF. There are plenty of free PDF converters out there (plugins for Word, built-in support in Mac OS X, standalone programs, etc etc). So I think at best iPaper is even with PDF in this regard.

Tangentially, PDF is not "bulky and painful". It just happens that Acrobat Reader is a ridiculously awful reader. Mac OS X handles PDFs like a breeze, they feel incredibly light weight as they open instantly and any application can output to them. So I whole-heartedly agree that Reader is a bad program, but don't extrapolate that to the format.

Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by zaidf on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:30PM (#119234)
Usability is one of Scribd's biggest selling points, which might resonate more with PC users long tired of Reader's unstability.

Technically PDF as a format might rock, but most users just care about how their experience is. People's idea of PDF is attached to their experience with Acrobat Reader.

Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by boucher on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:18PM (#119224)
"Can Acrobat Reader convert/read documents not in PDF format"

No. As such, this is a legitimate point for iPaper to make. They support more formats. Of course, many of the document creation programs do support conversion to PDF, but this is still a nice thing about iPaper.

But, it has nothing to do with the cost of creating documents. The cost to create an iPaper document is not zero, its undefined. You cannot create a document in iPaper, period. You must create that document some other way, be it MS Office, Adobe Acrobat, or one of their free alternatives, or a text editor.

If anything, they're advertising the cost to share a document. Which is free for every other type of document too, unless that person doesn't have a program to read the given file format, which is obviously the real thing iPaper should be trying to sell users on.

Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by tlrobinson on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:13PM (#119218)
I can't speak for Windows, but Mac OS X has always had PDF viewing and creation built in. It's as easy as selecting the "Print to PDF" button in any print dialog. 100% penetration on OS X.

Personally, I prefer a straight up link to a PDF. My browser can display it inline, and if I want to save it to my hard drive I just option-click.

Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by zaidf on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:22PM (#119229)
Acrobat Reader on Windows remains slow and unstable. Also, it hasn't ever come pre-installed for me.

Don't forget Mac's market share is still tiny compared to Windows, especially with businesses where PDF is used most.

Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by tolmasky on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:30PM (#119235)
Yeah, but if you care about the mobile market at all, then PDF is the way to go, given that Mobile Safari is the number 1 mobile browser and it supports PDF natively (as well as .doc)
Re:Scribd launches new platform and iPaper by boucher on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @06:08PM (#119270)
"Scribd takes that into account by stating PDF 'sometimes' requires download. I think that is fair--most marketers would just say 'yes' instead of 'sometimes.'"

My original point still stands. If its okay to say PDF requires a download sometimes, you really ought to be saying Flash requires a download sometimes. Anything less is dishonest.