News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by blackbagboys on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:10AM (#11914710)
I suppose I can't help but admire the chutzpah of cloaking a tax deductible scheme to drive down your labor costs as a noble quest to "advance human potential".

Now where did I put my black and red flags...

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by adwf on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:47AM (#11914826)
Whether you believe he is doing a good thing because it's a good thing, or just because he wants to be seen doing a good thing, it doesn't change the fact that the good thing is being done.

Tax deductibility does indeed incentivise charitable giving, possibly for selfish reasons. But the person on the recieving end of education/healthcare/whatever, doesn't really care do they? The effect is what's important, not the motivation.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by blackbagboys on Thursday June 16, 2016 @05:06AM (#11914899)
I don't believe that he is making this investment for either of those reasons. I believe he is making it because developing additional pools of low-cost contract labor is in the long term excellent for his business. Additionally, Andela will capture some of the delta between the cost of African and the cost of Indian or American developers, some of which will in turn be returned to the Initiative to finance future forays into making the world safe for oligopoly.

I am sure that some localized Good Things will occur as a byproduct of this arbitrage, but let's not pretend for a second that "advancing human potential" and "promoting equality" are actually the metrics by which the success of this enterprise is being judged.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by bko on Thursday June 16, 2016 @06:53AM (#11915283)
> low-cost contract labor

Phrases like that ring to me to describe a two class of people: a "low cost" tier, and a "normal cost" tier. To me this has obvious racist overtones as "low-cost" is often followed by [nationality]. If someone is willing to work harder, she should get the job, but somehow if that same person is willing to work as hard for less money, she is unworthy? Sure the company benefits from a spread between what a person makes and what they contribute, but they do so already. Eventually if that spread becomes too large, other companies will exploit this arbitrage and start new businesses and bid up the employees compensation. You are free to do so as well assuming you live in a free capitalist society.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by Sacho on Thursday June 16, 2016 @07:15AM (#11915352)
They're willing to work for less because in their local economy, the pay is actually good to great.

This destabilizes the local economy, creating gentrified districts or entire cities(See: SF) where only the privileged laborers for a foreign economy can afford to live. It will also lead to a sharp increase in luxury good prices due to new demand, driving the bar for middle-class living out of reach for local workers. The skilled workers hired by the foreign economy become a brain drain - the government has invested resources into their education, but no one in the local economy can afford them, thus they'll never create goods for it to improve local technology levels.

Helping people is hard.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by Cybiote on Thursday June 16, 2016 @08:03AM (#11915524)
In those countries, corruption and the resource curse have already more than decimated local economies, creating a very lopsided distribution of wealth. It is difficult to conceive of an orthogonal infusion of wealth generation as worsening their already horrid state of affairs.

With corruption having bled those countries dry, there remains little by way of local engineering opportunities and those able to, leave. A local training hub as Andela is difficult to see as worsening that situation.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by bko on Thursday June 16, 2016 @08:45AM (#11915698)
> This destabilizes the local economy, creating gentrified districts or entire cities(See: SF)

So paying people more and giving them jobs destabilizes the local economy because these people now have money and spend more on housing and other items? And if they're paid less, they're being exploited?

> The skilled workers hired by the foreign economy become a brain drain - the government has invested resources into their education, but no one in the local economy can afford them, thus they'll never create goods for it to improve local technology levels.

Doesn't the government prefer rich denizens and a higher tax base? Isn't this how education is funded and higher salaries and tax base partially the point of investing in education?

> but no one in the local economy can afford them, thus they'll never create goods for it to improve local technology levels.

Aren't digital good mostly global in nature? Don't poor countries benefit from Facebook/Google/Apple/etc?

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by Sacho on Thursday June 16, 2016 @09:11AM (#11915825)
> So paying people more and giving them jobs destabilizes the local economy because these people now have money and spend more on housing and other items? And if they're paid less, they're being exploited?

You're not paying all people more, just some of them. The rest get to enjoy rising prices for good housing and luxuries that they won't be able to afford with their local pay.

> Doesn't the government prefer rich denizens and a higher tax base? Isn't this how education is funded and higher salaries and tax base partially the point of investing in education?

Unless you're planning to turn all Nigerians and Kenyans into software developers, this isn't really the case. Just higher taxes may pay for the education the government invested in you, but the investment is made with a hope that you would do more than break even. Without skilled technological leaders driving progress forward(because they're busy driving someone else's progress forward), you'll stagnate, which means the costs of global goods gets worse for your population,

> Aren't digital good mostly global in nature? Don't poor countries benefit from Facebook/Google/Apple/etc?

Yes - which is why most poor countries can't afford them.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by bko on Thursday June 16, 2016 @09:36AM (#11915963)
> You're not paying all people more, just some of them. The rest get to enjoy rising prices for good housing and luxuries that they won't be able to afford with their local pay.

Correct, gains are never distributed equally. This has been tried and failed. You can keep everyone poor or allow some to accumulate wealth.

In regards to modern technology not benefiting poor countries, please note that more people in Africa have a mobile phone than access to electricity [0]. Across the seven countries surveyed, roughly two-thirds or more say they own a cell phone. Ownership is especially high in South Africa and Nigeria, where about nine-in-ten have a cell phone [1]. I think you're understating the positive impact western technology is having on transforming the lives of poor Africans.

[0] http://www.cnn.com/2012/10/04/tech/mobile/africa-mobile-opin...

[1] http://www.pewglobal.org/2015/04/15/cell-phones-in-africa-co...

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by MrsPeaches on Thursday June 16, 2016 @12:54PM (#11917320)
More people have access to mobile phones than running water, basic drainage or paves roads. Mobile phone penetration in Africa now stands at 93% [1]

I would however question the extent this is driven by Western innovation though. I would argue that this driven primarily through the ability of the Chinese to make technology for a significantly lower cost.

[1] http://edition.cnn.com/2016/01/19/africa/africa-afrobaromete...

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by rdlecler1 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @05:27AM (#11914989)
You could make the argument that any of his investments will be in his long term self interest. Even investing in an anti-Facebook could be seen as a self interested move "Oh, this is to show that he doesn't support monopoly"
Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by q5 on Thursday June 16, 2016 @08:17AM (#11915580)
One issue with the argument you presented is that a not-for-profit or charitable entity by definition does not have profit in its interest. For-profit entities also have the liberty to freely move their capital to satisfy their business requirements.

Although there is no law against a charity or not-for-profit deciding to remove funding for a program they, by definition, are not motivated by the money flow of the program. Sure they are interested in making the program run efficiently and that there is enough funding to begin the program and see the program through but profit is not their core motivation and thus, I would argue, are more committed in their programs and investments. Those exploiting inefficiencies for gain should be reprimanded by the system granting these special business types.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by lazaroclapp on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:30AM (#11914777)
Doesn't it do both of those, plus also potentially open Facebook to being out-competed by a Nigerian or Kenyan software company?

Even if his particular brand of education is in the particular areas in which his company employs people (note that it is also his own personal area of education and expertise), I don't think that should be enough to dismiss funding education as a valid tax deductible charity. Now, if in the next months it emerges that this coding schools teach only FB specific technologies (e.g. something like how to build a Messenger bot, I don't even mean PHP/Hack or React) or that admission is contingent in signing a contract to work for FB afterwards, I would feel very differently.

To put an extreme example, do you consider the companies listed here: http://www.blackgirlscode.com/partners.html to also be participating in a tax deductible anti-labor scheme? If not, where is the line?

Sure, maybe at some point Zuckerberg will realize, like Gates did before him, that the world still needs more anti-malaria drugs and nets, before it needs computers and programming courses. Nonetheless, education initiatives (even highly-targeted professional-skill education initiatives) are charities and do produce a public benefit. Whether or not that benefit exceeds the benefit produced by the taxes that would otherwise have been collected leads to a lengthy policy discussion about when and how to tax charitable donations, which might indeed be an option.

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by blackbagboys on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:49AM (#11914833)
Andela's business model is to provide low-cost contract labor to large tech firms. This is of course delightful for those African students who benefit from the program and from a business perspective a wise investment by the Chan Zuckerbeg slush fund. I only wish that they would dispense with the nauseatingly self-congratulatory marketing copy.
Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by lazaroclapp on Thursday June 16, 2016 @05:19AM (#11914962)
Interesting. I was unaware of this, I thought this was an entirely non-profit code school type program. Is training contingent on them working for Andela afterwards? Because if so, I actually fail to see how this can be considered a nonprofit investment (in which case, I agree, it is a good business deal for everyone involved and maybe even a net-positive-do-good business deal, but one that should probably be taxed... )

Edit: I just realized this indeed an investment from a for-profit company to another, which will actually pay taxes (which is good), but seems to be surprisingly describing itself as a philanthropic initiative. So I actually see your point about this being a strange PR spin on it...

Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by nl on Thursday June 16, 2016 @08:25AM (#11915622)
There are plenty of existing software outsourcing companies. For your argument to make sense you'll need to explain why FB doesn't use them already if cost control is his motivation here.
Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by cpach on Thursday June 16, 2016 @04:39AM (#11914800)
Huh? Would you rather see less educational opportunities for African citizens?
Re:The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative makes its first investment by igk on Thursday June 16, 2016 @06:52AM (#11915277)
I'd rather see some which are honest about wanting to exploit the cost of living diffential instead of acting like charity, or some which are actually nonprofit charities, not startups like Angela and tax optimisation schemes like zuckerbergs fund