News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by huherto on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @02:37PM (#119121)
I think it is sad that we are discussing weather or not the story should be in HN. I would rather like to see a smart discussion on the actual event from all the smart people here. For starters: what is going to happen to cuba now? Should the embargo end?
Re:Fidel Castro retires by hugh on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @04:02PM (#119175)
I can't see that it should end immediately -- the conditions under which it was started are still in place. However, it's probably a good opportunity to start negotiations with whoever takes over -- a gradual lifting of the embargo in exchange for democratic reforms, release of political prisoners, a timetable for free elections etc.
Re:Fidel Castro retires by mariorz on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @04:28PM (#119184)
The conditions didn't change (ergo the embargo failed in it's intent) only causing more economic problems for the people you claim to be trying to save, and you want to keep it up?
Re:Fidel Castro retires by hugh on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:12PM (#119216)
No, I want to see it lifted, in exchange for democratic reforms.

Whether or not it was a good idea in the first place, it's in place now, so lifting it is one of the few carrots which the US can offer the Cuban regime. It seems silly to give up that carrot without extracting some sort of concession, particularly as the post-Fidel government may be more amenable to compromise.

If the US were to unilaterally lift the embargo without any movement by the Cuban government then it's not clear whether that would accelerate or decelerate the cause of human rights. However, making a deal has got to at least be worth a try, assuming our goal is a Cuba where people can speak freely, travel freely, own property, vote in freely contested elections, use the internet, and start businesses (to bring the topic back round to something marginally relevant to HN).

Re:Fidel Castro retires by mariorz on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @05:36PM (#119241)
Yes those are our goals, but they will not be achieved by maintaining an embargo as the last 40? 50? years have shown... You can't just force or pressure countries into "democracy", that is not the way it works, there are more than enough examples in recent U.S. history that hint at this...

Even if you could, the whole premise of the embargo is flawed I think.. it only makes the cuban government look like a "martyr", in this case to the imperialist whims of the U.S. etc.

Re:Fidel Castro retires by mariorz on Tuesday February 19, 2008 @03:47PM (#119162)
The embargo should have never existed.