News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by djrobstep on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @08:40AM (#11908907)
Money talks. We need to shift the tax burden to encourage higher density land use.

We need high enough land taxes on the highest value land to encourage high density buildings on that land.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by themartorana on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @08:59AM (#11909022)
Do we, though? I agree encouraging density in the places people want to live densely is a Good Idea - think SF, NYC, etc. People and entrenched interests working to prevent density where appropriate are worth defeating.

That said, some people want to live in sprawling suburbs, and taxing them unnecessarily for the inconvenience seems like a Bad Idea.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by jimlawruk on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @10:17AM (#11909440)
I grew up thinking I wanted to live in the suburbs with a large lot/house, etc. Then after living in a small place where you can walk everywhere, I realized smaller is actually better. I suspect many like me could come to that realization. Also, many people "wish" they could live in a city, but are forced to the suburbs due practical reasons: lower cost housing and better schools.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by lettergram on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:06AM (#11909759)
Interesting, I grew up in the suburbs and hate living in cities. I live in the bay area at the moment, and even that is a bit crammed for me.

The suburbs give you space to do stuff. I grew up on the out skirts of the Chicago suburbs and I could play soccer, go mountain biking, off road, and in the same day go to any store or restaurant you can think of. More in less space might be great, for some, but you still can't fit everything in one place.

The suburbs may require a bit of driving, but it's less dense and thus you have less traffic (easy to drive 10 miles in 15 minutes) so you get a lot more in a given area you have access to.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by hx87 on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:20AM (#11909832)
Timewise, cities aren't that much further from the wilderness than suburbs are. There are certainly advantages to living in suburbs, space being the primary one, but time isn't one of them.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by lettergram on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @12:09PM (#11910168)
I am 100% sure people in Boston, NYC, the Bay Area, downtown Chicago, etc. would strongly disagree that it takes 15 minutes or less to get to a place to hike, horse back ride, and/or fish.

Having lived in the Chicago suburbs, downtown Chicago, Champaign, IL and the Bay Area; assuming you live in a suburb (as opposed to Champaign, IL) you'll have access to a much larger variety of places to go in the suburbs. I will however agree that going out to bars, or traveling via foot/public transit would be difficult.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by cafard on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @01:26PM (#11910670)
I'm cheating here because I live in Washington, DC, and in an area close to Rock Creek Park. But in order if time to get there: the hiking trails of Rock Creek Park, about 10 minutes walking; the nearest riding stables, about 10 minutes driving; fishing at Roaches Run, 25 minutes driving in light traffic.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by arebop on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @01:20PM (#11910633)
Let's say 30 minutes [https://goo.gl/maps/SjMUzazkmUy]. Is that "much further" than 15 minutes?
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by thescriptkiddie on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @03:37PM (#11911555)
This is only true because you have to drive through the wasteland that is the suburbs to get out of the city. In places without such excessive suburban sprawl you can get out of the city much more easily.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by ajmurmann on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @10:33AM (#11909566)
We are currently subsidizing living in low density areas. The per capita cost of streets, sewer, etc. is much, much higher in the suburbs. We should at least stop the subsidies.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by nitrogen on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @12:10PM (#11910177)
Show me the line item on a bedroom community city's budget that says "subsidy from self-righteous city dwellers who don't realize the employees of the companies that pay taxes to the city commute from suburbs".
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by pm90 on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @12:23PM (#11910248)
This kind of attitude is not welcome on HN. We are a friendly community that welcomes different opinions/views which are debated in a professional way.

Even so, here [0] is a recent HN article which does a very good job of explaining how suburbs are predicated on an (unsustainable) model of growth.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11638849

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by nitrogen on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @07:32PM (#11912907)
Do you not see how the constant accusations against suburbanites of leeching off the cities is equally antagonistic? It happens frequently on HN -- someone might post about inefficiencies of suburbs for transportation (often, but not always true) or the use of water for growing food in rural areas, then a bunch of others will pile on with escalating disdain for non-city life. But because the escalation is gradual and the disdain is so popular here, nobody notices that they've slid into an endless pit of belittling the roots of millions of people.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by pm90 on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:04PM (#11913643)
I was referring to the way you made your point rather than your point itself. I apologize if I was not clear.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by nitrogen on Thursday June 16, 2016 @12:57AM (#11914100)
Yeah, occasionally I get a bit frustrated by this topic and it shows in the tone of my comments. Hopefully it illustrates the point, though, that there's a need for nuance and understanding on both sides.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by ajmurmann on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @02:58PM (#11911248)
I strongly recommend the episode of econtalk on this: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/05/charles_marohn.html
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by jacobolus on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @09:17AM (#11909109)
Making the suburbs pay for their own infrastructure is not “taxing them unnecessarily”.

Currently suburban infrastructure and the automobile commuter pattern of life is heavily subsidized, while other development patterns are penalized or banned outright.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by raldi on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @10:00AM (#11909345)
And let's not forget their carbon footprint.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by Agustus on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @10:30AM (#11909549)
How is suburban infrastructure heavily subsidized?
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by ajmurmann on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @10:36AM (#11909582)
Everyone pays the same for infrastructure regardless if you live in a low or high density part of town. However, you require more infrastructure living in the suburbs. Only two other families ever use the piece of street in front of my house. At best a hundred families ever use the small park across the street.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by ghaff on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:01AM (#11909729)
>Everyone pays the same for infrastructure regardless if you live in a low or high density part of town.

No actually. A heavily subsidized project like the Big Dig cost vastly more per mile than a suburban side street.

Furthermore, you can't just assume that cities could exist in isolation. The inhabitants wouldn't last long without numerous inputs (food, water, power, etc.) that they can't provide for themselves and that require areas with less density to produce for them.

It's very hard to come up with numbers because everything is effectively a large interconnected system. Some patterns are probably more efficient than others but you can't just assume everyone into urban living.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by jacobolus on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:26AM (#11909883)
The Big Dig is part of a transportation system designed to help people who live in the suburbs commute by car into the city to work. If everyone who worked in the city could also live there, there would be much less need for massive highways. As local transportation, the subway and buses are much more scalable and efficient. (Not to mention just walking.)

Residential sprawl in the suburbs is not producing food, etc. Nobody is advocating turning all cropland into city, that wouldn’t make any sense.

The advocacy is for changing tax/zoning/planning policy to encourage residential density and mixed residential-commercial use neighborhoods. Even in towns of, say, 30k people, having a denser town center full of low-rise apartment buildings and walkable neighborhoods is a big advantage for economic efficiency, for human health, and for the environment.

Having people commute one-person-per-car for 1–2 hours per day, drive cars to school, to shops, to restaurants, to the post office and the library, ... is ridiculously destructive at a societal scale. All the public infrastructure and public services cost several times as much per capita as life at higher density, not even to mention the economic/environmental cost of the cars themselves, or the massive time opportunity cost of the commuting.

> you can't just assume everyone into urban living.

Nope. But people who want to live somewhere very economically wasteful should be prepared to pay for it.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by ajmurmann on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:28AM (#11909896)
Of course the Big Dig is more expensive, but you can't compare a single road to another road. If you take all roads in one area and divide it by the number of users you get a much more meaningful number.

Of course you are completely right that we need rural areas where we for example grow good or do other things that need lots of space. However, that doesn't happen in most suburbs. In fact suburbs typically keep their density artificially low for non other than vague aesthetic reasons. I myself live in the suburbs and find it very convenient. Would I do so if I had to pay for the street and sewer that lead to my house like my parents who live in Germany had to? Probably not. My parents had to pay about 20k, and that was because most of their property was on a main, federal road. Otherwise it would have been closer to 40. At the time I thought that was insane, but given that in a multi story apartment building the cost would have been much lower, it seems fair in hindsight.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by ghaff on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:41AM (#11909978)
In the US town where I live, which is admittedly more exurban/rural than suburban, I pay for my own septic system, trash, water, etc. Houses that were hooked up to sewer in another part of town a number of years back had to pay for that. No, in the US, you don't typically pay for public roads although people certainly pay for upkeep when they are on private roads as some are. (I'm off a state highway and have to handle the upkeep of my long private driveway.)

Personally, I'm no particular fan of traditional suburbs. But I'm also unconvinced that it's even desirable to especially encourage urban living--especially if, in practice, that means encouraging living in a few specific walkable cities. Presumably urban living in this context doesn't mean Las Vegas.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by Agustus on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:20AM (#11909837)
The park is not part of infrastructure. It is a perk that the government decided to be responsible for that is a vestige of urbanized planners taking cues from New York and Philadelphia. Your street is part of a system that was put in place through the urban planners and is probably maintained by the municipality, if you would like to volunteer to not have them maintain it, you can always ask them to.

* Streets are paid for in the United States through the gas taxes collected from the distribution of fuels. It is a user tax.

* Water and electricity are maintained and run by utilities through their use rates. I will pre-empt the discourse and note that water is heavily subsidized by the government and creates weird incentives (I am looking at you Arizona with your green lawns).

* Transit, bicycle, and pedestrian movements are subsidized by the gas tax. In this case, your statement would be true.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by jacobolus on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @11:44AM (#11910003)
> Streets are paid for in the United States through the gas taxes collected from the distribution of fuels. It is a user tax.

This is not the whole story.

http://taxfoundation.org/article/gasoline-taxes-and-user-fee... (ignore the advocacy here, just look at the numbers)

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by Agustus on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @01:27PM (#11910682)
The way this is set up means that the content creator has no idea how funding works.

1. Toll revenue goes to toll facilities. Private public partnerships (PPP's) need to be repaid and the tolls collected go directly to the repayment of the bonds, maintenance, and general operations.

2. Transit siphons monies away from the use tax. Transit exists only because of the user tax. While people see autos as bad, they fund the transit that provides movement for poor individuals. I am okay with this.

3. State and local roads is oddly worded in this phrase and brings a warning to my periphery review. Most states have amendments and/charters that require fuel funds to be allocated to the roadways, Wisconsin (http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/Finance/fueltaxes.htm), Florida, and a number of others that do not take money from other sources. In fact in Florida, the highway funds are raided yearly to fill in budget gaps.

The best I can come up with on how this chart was made to get the 50% concept is that FHWA provides matching funds for projects, the reason is that they want to provide a carrot to meet federally required mandates, such as interstates and state roads on the National Highway System. If you kick in these monies, which is free money, then you can get there. However, this is an advocacy program.

One last note. The writing is on the wall for the gas tax long term. The federal level is already having a shortfall in revenue because of the CAFE standards increase. This is why states like Oregon are trying out the Vehicle Miles Traveled tax, because they need to switch out how the roadways are paid for.

Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by raldi on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @05:21PM (#11912234)
For starters, by spending trillions of dollars on wars in the Middle East to keep fuel prices low. We also set the gas tax far too low to account for all the negative externalities of driving.
Re:Costs of Sprawl: The Speed Burden (2014) by djrobstep on Wednesday June 15, 2016 @09:15AM (#11909101)
Shifting more of the tax burden onto expensive land shifts it off cheaper land.