News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi by Animats on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:23PM (#11899121)
"This points out a fundamental problem with programmable financial assets: there are so many degrees of freedom that it's difficult to compare asset prices and perform arbitrage. In fact, I would not be surprised if the developers purposefully made their contracts complex to discourage such comparisons. Additional complexity also makes it difficult for the investors to figure out what exactly they are buying. Why should someone who wants to exit a crowd-funding vehicle follow a weird software engineering pattern that is tantamount to buying a timelocked asset? What exactly happens to the reward tokens of The DAO through splits? Why is this stuff so needlessly complicated?"

This sounds all too much like Paycoin. Paycoin was a competitor to Bitcoin, but it was much more complicated. There was a claimed guarantee that the price of Paycoin would not fall below $20. (The current price of Paycoin is $0.01212923.) There was a connection to a Bitcoin mining operation, GAW miners. There was BanxShares, which was some kind of derivative based on Paycoin and backed by a porno site.[1] There were ZenCloud and PayBase. There was a Paycoin Foundation. There was supposedly a reserve in US dollars backing Paycoin.[2] There was a "Hybrid Flex Blockchain" to provide faster confirmations.

The result was a disaster.[3]

There's a long history of complicated Ponzi-like things. Sergei Mavrodi did it twice, once in the 1990s with "MMM" in Russia, [4], and again, after doing jail time, as Bitcoin-based "MMM Global" in the 2010s.[5] MMM was a combination lending network, pyramid scheme with a downline, and Ponzi. It collapsed both times, of course.

Warren Buffett on overly complex finance: [6]

[1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=813191.0 [2] http://web.archive.org/web/20150214110136/https://paycoin.co... [3] https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/death-paycoin-employee-... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MMM_%28Ponzi_scheme_company%29 [5] http://www.fin24.com/Money/Investments/alleged-sa-ponzi-sche... [6] http://www.buffettsecrets.com/understanding-the-company.htm

Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi by rahimnathwani on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @03:11AM (#11900316)
The Warren Buffet article you linked isn't relevant to your main point. The article is not about overly-complex finance. It's about overly-complex companies. If you're buying a security (e.g. A particular class of convertible debt of a company) then there are two things that you need to analyse: the issuer (the company), and the properties (rights, payoffs, optionality) in the security itself.

I believe that Buffet et al shy away from complicated companies (as they're too hard to understand) but look for securities that are mispriced, which are sometimes of the more complex variety, rather than just straight equity.

Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi by kolinko on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @04:51AM (#11900675)
The differnce is that in TheDao the money is protected by a smart contract. It's auditable by anyone and securely locked - literally no single person or entity owns keys to the lock.

In case of Paycoin, and many other similar scenarios, you had to trust the company.

Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi by joosters on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @05:37AM (#11900817)
Audits aren't that useful, the DAO was 'audited' soon after creation and none of its flaws were found: https://blog.slock.it/deja-vu-dao-smart-contracts-audit-resu...
Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi by aminorex on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @05:01AM (#11900706)
Auditability in principle is good in principle. Actual audits in actual practice, on the other hand, would be actually good.
Re:Caution: The DAO Can Turn into a Naturally-Arising Ponzi by Bartweiss on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @09:29AM (#11901869)
"In theory, theory and practice are the same..."