Re:Vint Cerf: Introducing the People-Centered Internet Newsl...
by krapp on Monday June 13, 2016 @07:37PM
(#11898660)
If users choose to advertise, a user-centric communication medium would allow them to do so. To ban advertisements outright would be censorship.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Vint Cerf: Introducing the People-Centered Internet Newsl...
by eevilspock on Monday June 13, 2016 @10:38PM
(#11899401)
He didn't say "ban" much less "ban outright", did he? The list is "desirable properties".
I agree with his characterization of advertising, and that to be "people centric", there would be no ads by definition.
Re:Vint Cerf: Introducing the People-Centered Internet Newsl...
by krapp on Monday June 13, 2016 @11:50PM
(#11899629)
I'm not a huge fan of advertising on the web, I think it's doomed to failure. But I disagree that it's desirable to be rid of advertising.
And I only say that because I believe freedom of expression - and that includes commercial expression - is sacrosanct. In my opinion, a truly "people centric" platform allows my right to serve whatever I want (within the bounds of the law) to supercede anyone else's personal ethics.
Re:Vint Cerf: Introducing the People-Centered Internet Newsl...
by eevilspock on Monday June 13, 2016 @11:59PM
(#11899667)
Just because freedom allows you to say most anything doesn't mean all those things are consistent with freedom. One can protect the KKK's right to free speech while simultaneously saying that their speech is undesirable and inconsistent with freedom.
The same principle applies to "people centric".
I think you keep inserting "ban" into what you're responding to when no one is saying that. Try rereading the article and the parent comments without that bias.