News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hints of an unexpected new particle could be confirmed wi... by ThePhysicist on Monday June 13, 2016 @12:14PM (#11895031)
I think the difference that the author wants to stress here is that this new particle would be something that no one has predicted. The discovery of the Higgs, on the other hand, was an experiment that confirmed a theory which had been formulated several decades ago. And while this is also an amazing achievement, finding a particle that can't be accounted for with our current theories is much more exciting (to me at least), as it means that our current understanding of particle physics is fundamentally or at least partially wrong.

This, I think, is exactly the kind of discovery that people expected from the LHC: Something new and exciting that invalidates our current theories and gives us a possibility to devise / test new ones against real experimental data. After all, the real shortage in particle physics is not the number of theories (we can invent a quasi infinite number of them), but the data against which we can test them.

Re:Hints of an unexpected new particle could be confirmed wi... by ifdefdebug on Monday June 13, 2016 @01:33PM (#11895618)
As I see it, before the Higgs was seen, this search was also a search for "new physics", because if Higgs was wrong, a lot of new physics would have been needed to explain the things Higgs was trying to explain. It's just that everybody was expecting a confirmation because all of the rest of the SM turned out to be right so far, so nobody really expected new physics to come from there.

Now since the last chance of "new physics" due to the lack of a signal where a signal should have been is gone, everybody turns their hope to finding a signal where no signal was expected. This is of course totally legitimated, but it doesn't take away any of the importance of the former.

I would love to see something new too, but if the SM explains everything we are able to measure today just fine, then be it. Then the SM is all we need, until we are able to measure more. It's just like the people in the 19th century: they had to go with Newton because they couldn't measure anything beyond Newton. But on the other hand, back then Newton was all they needed, because Newton could explain everything they saw.

Re:Hints of an unexpected new particle could be confirmed wi... by acqq on Monday June 13, 2016 @06:14PM (#11898175)
> people in the 19th century: they had to go with Newton because they couldn't measure anything beyond Newton

As far as I know in 19th century there were already the measurements and the calculations resulting from them that didn't match Newton's model.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbain_Le_Verrier#Precession_o...

By the way, Le Verrier also discovered Neptune just by studying the measured movements of the known planets.

Re:Hints of an unexpected new particle could be confirmed wi... by ifdefdebug on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @04:09AM (#11900525)
I stand corrected. Please read my sentence as: "in the 18th and early 19th century".
Re:Hints of an unexpected new particle could be confirmed wi... by SubiculumCode on Monday June 13, 2016 @07:06PM (#11898498)
You can't disprove a null, just fail to reject the null. Failing to find the Higgs would not have provided evidence that the Higgs did not exist.
Re:Hints of an unexpected new particle could be confirmed wi... by ThePhysicist on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @01:30AM (#11899986)
Yes, exactly! That's why finding unknown particles is so interesting, as it can invalidate a given theory.