Nobody seemed able to know what a high quality question was, nor could come to an agreement on what topics specifically would be allowed.
I left the community and became a mod a year later because stackexchange asked me to - given that I had a high reputation on the site and the site itself was in danger of dying out. The site still exists today IMO, in spite of the users who are quick to criticize other peoples questions instead of answer them - and really because the topic itself is something a lot of people are interested in without a lot of other communities to go to for support.
Stackexchange's system encourages people to be bitchy and put down other people's questions. They are in the position they are because of SEO - and because google and yahoo's alternative solutions were short sighted. If the monetization model was really all that strong they would lose their market position very quickly.
It's good that there are rules, but what really matters is the community. People are on there are trying to get help following their passion or making their living. The stakes are often very high for the asker, making a rude response particularly painful.
I was messing around with Elixir (which is newish in the scheme of thing) and it's very different than asking about Rails/Ruby.
You may believe the current rules and moderator brute squads work to keep the site clean, but from where i'm standing they work to make the site useless.