News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by tuna-piano on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:51PM (#11885753)
Supply and demand explains all.

When more people want something than there are available, prices increase - until the price increases enough to ration the available supply to the highest bidders.

For those calling for rent control, they are advocating a different method of rationing the available apartments... leaving multiple interested people for one apartment. Why is the non-price way of rationing better than rationing based on who is willing to pay the most? Some people still won't be able to live where they want to live, it just won't be because they can't afford to.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by pash on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:39PM (#11885920)
> Why is the non-price way of rationing better than rationing based on who is willing to pay the most?

It's not. But rationing by price has little advantage if you're not going to allow anybody to build more housing: the basic benefit of the price mechanism is that higher prices recruit more resources to employ towards increasing supply. But if you're going to fix supply though a NIMBY-dominated political process, then every dollar of increased rent is going to end up in the pockets of property-owners, not budging the supply of housing, to the unallayed detriment of renters.

This is a both a partial explanation of why NIMBY-ism is so pernicious and of why capital (foreign or otherwise) is so strongly attracted to NIMBY-dominated, supply-constrained markets like the Bay Area.

The quality of commentary on these issues in the press and in the political process is abhorrent. If anyone with a basic understanding of economics is interested in learning more about the economics of rationing, I recommend starting with Economic Analysis of Property Rights, by Yoram Barzel [0,1].

0. Publisher's site: http://www.cambridge.org/us/academic/subjects/economics/indu...

1. Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/Economic-Analysis-Political-Instituti...

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by sokoloff on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:19PM (#11886048)
I'd argue that higher prices also mean the resources are consumed by those with the greatest need (as demonstrated by willingness to pay).

Take another example. After Katrina hit, some stores got investigated for "gouging" on water. Obviously, water is a necessity of life, post-Katrina municipal water supplies were unavailable in many areas.

Now, imagine that it was selling for $1/gallon two weeks prior to Katrina. What's the "best" price for the water to sell one day after Katrina? $1/gallon will likely yield rampant hoarding and scarcity of water for someone who might need it. Allowing the price to float will ensure that someone who really needs water will be able to buy it, though the price might be $5/gallon. I'd rather have thirsty people paying $5/gallon and drinking clean water than having a few AHs having hundreds of gallons of surplus water and no water available for sale. This is how I view rent control.

This would also serve as a strong pull signal to get more water into the area, but I suspect that was already underway.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by alistairSH on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:30PM (#11886220)
Allowing the price to float will ensure that someone who really needs water will be able to buy it

That isn't going to be true in the extreme. Three people need water. Two are wealthy, one is not. The two wealthy buyers bid up the price to the point the non-wealthy buyer is priced out o the market. Without some for of rationing (or a change in supply), the non-wealthy buyer dies from dehydration.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by pash on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:38PM (#11886235)
Yes, you're right, more or less. (And this is the reason I edited my post to claim "little advantage" rather than "no advantage" from increased prices, possibly after you replied to it.)

But analyzing the effect you've described is much more difficult than analyzing the effect of price increases in a market in which supply is not artificially constrained: some people have more or less money than others, and are more or less ready to spend it on this or that, for various reasons. And it is not nearly as straightforward to say that there will be a social benefit (in whatever sense you prefer) in letting the highest bidder claim a resource when the proceeds will go fully into someone's pocket rather than when they are likely to lead to higher production of the resource, and thence to an obviously greater social benefit from its higher consumption.

Of course, I expect that you are right in at least the sense you meant: in the presence of a constraint on supply, the price mechanism will still broadly incentivize people who derive a greater benefit from consuming the resource actually to consume it: higher rents will mean more tech types in the Bay Area.

I must point out here that nothing happens in isolation. Higher rents in the Bay Area will incentivize employers to move jobs elsewhere, all else equal. (I have seen several instances of this is my home, Kansas City, which is becoming a popular place to park back-office jobs for San Francisco firms of national scope.) And, yes, providing that incentive to move out is a good thing, relative to the theoretical alternative of paying higher rents without that option, and consequently transferring resources to property-owners with no net social benefit. But it's still a poor alternative to letting higher prices do what they want to do in the absence of artificial constraints: increase supply of a resource whose higher consumption benefits society on net.

Still, if you want to limit development and push people to move to Kansas City because San Francisco's rents are too damn high, please, do. It's a much more appealing place than costal ignorance would lead you to believe, and we will welcome the newcomers.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by tuna-piano on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:33PM (#11886493)
Thanks for the book recommendations. Obviously, I haven't read them yet, but I think my next point will still be valid.

In situations of natural fixed supply, think real estate in times square, water after Katrina, rare collectors items - the price is still extremely important for rationing. And the price does lead to the highest value activities performed.

For example, in times square, you see mass market wide popularity businesses - you don't see niche computer parts stores (which you might if rent was capped at $500 per store per month). Nothing to do with NIMBY.

In this case, if rent control was established, people that would be willing to commute from further away might end up living closer, while those who want to pay more to commute less may be forced to live further away. Exactly the sub-optimal economic situation.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by curun1r on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:41PM (#11886242)
A market-based approach would make a lot of sense in a world that doesn't have Prop 13. Then property owners would be forced to balance their objections to new development with the fact that the lack of new development will push up property values and increase property taxes. But with a cap on property taxes, existing property owners are free to block, stall and otherwise prevent new development without any financial disincentive.

As you've pointed out, supply and demand explains all. But supply has been limited by forces that need to be fixed. We either need some financial pressure that convinces property owners that new development is in their best interests or we need to stop giving existing property owners input on new development. Because demand is increasing, whether we like it or not. And in the face of that, there are only two options, build more or let rents spike. When even Google employees are feeling the pain of high rents, it's obvious we're not striking the right balance between those two options.

It's annoying to see the focus on stuff like rent control when the underlying cause is so clear. Prop 13 is at the core of these problems and needs to be addressed directly rather than tangential half measures like rent control.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by jchrisa on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:18PM (#11886189)
There's also the argument that economic diversity is good for everyone. Non-market solutions to maintaining space for people of different income levels in the area might have positive externalities.
Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by alexmat on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:36PM (#11886231)
Just as a fun thought experiment, let's say we price all the service workers at current income levels out of the market so they all move away. At some point, people will be willing to pay more for service work due to a strong demand for limited services.

It almost seems pernicious to have low income housing since it allows employers to get away with lower wages to cover an artificially low cost of housing, at the same time, service workers retain a poor quality of life because outside housing everything else is expensive.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by tuna-piano on Saturday June 11, 2016 @11:52PM (#11886557)
Your first point is definitely correct, one example (a mix of factors) would be the $17+ wages for Walmart and fast food workers in North Dakota energy boom towns(1).

Your second point is interesting, but I suspect only partially correct. I imagine subsidizing service workers to live in low income housing does allow businesses to pay service workers less in those areas. However, if those low income housing units were not the service workers best option - they wouldn't live there. So I would imagine overall that it does help the service workers, not hurt them.

http://dailysignal.com/2014/06/10/drilling-innovation-forcin...

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by alexmat on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:22PM (#11896013)
Thanks for the link, that's exactly what I had in mind!
Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by pappyo on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:24PM (#11885875)
Because you've turned a "neighborhood" into an "investment property." Neighborhoods develop culture. Investment properties develop nothing other than capital that leaves the neighborhood.

What happens when the Silicon Valley boom is over? What happen to those neighborhoods? I guess that's not your problem.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by throwaway76543 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @07:58PM (#11885976)
This is utter nonsense. There's no evidence that neighborhoods made up of renters are any more or less "cultural" than neighborhoods made up of, well, you haven't really articulated an alternative have you? Do you expect everyone to purchase a home, and not have renting at all?

Generally areas regarded as having a vibrant culture also correlate with high percentages of renters -- because they're in cities. Areas with high percentages of homeowners and low percentages of renters tend to be suburbs.

In any event we can answer your question of what happens when the boom is over because we've already lived through two tech booms in this area. The answer is: Prices fall and folks with investment properties will lose some money but not much else changes. Homeowners get hurt a lot more than renters when bubbles pop.

Re:In Silicon Valley Suburbs, Calls to Limit the Soaring Rents by raldi on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:20PM (#11886052)
> What happens when the Silicon Valley boom is over? What happen to those neighborhoods?

When the supply of SF housing overtook demand in the late 1960s, and this oversupply led to incredibly-affordable rooms, it brought about the Summer of Love.