Re:What If PTSD Is More Physical Than Psychological? Evidenc...
by vwcx on Sunday June 12, 2016 @09:39AM
(#11888032)
Yeah, and in some ways, the new study is a complete return to 150+ years ago. In the American Civil War, a theory of "windage" was put forward, that the concussion from a projectile's blast was responsible for "soldier's heart" in the head.
And don't forget the stories in the late 1800s in the UK related to "railway spine" -- the documentation of psychosomatic effects following a railroad accident, attributed to torsion of the spine and brainstem.
That is not really an accurate picture. There was more than just Mott with that view even in the World War I era, and the article forgets one minor European war between World War I and the Balkan Wars, during which the question was reopened, with a number of physicians in the 1930s-50s arguing for a physical cause. The article wants to position this as a radical new proposal overturning 100 years of ironclad consensus, while in reality it's more of a recurring proposal that has had periodic champions.