News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mistrust of Science by jerf on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:13PM (#11884261)
As much fun as the long thread now dangling beneath your post is, it also misses the point. The point is that all of what yummyfajitas posted can be backed up with peer-reviewed reliable research. As for the fact that many, most, or even all of them can also be contradicted by reliable peer-reviewed research, well, it may win the battle but lose the war to argue that. If science can produce peer-reviewed contradictory research... and it most assuredly can, because that's basically by design and broadly a good thing... then on what basis do you attack the public for the preference it shows for one side or another of the peer-reviewed research?

If I or the public in general agree with a position that only 30% of the "real scientists" in a field hold, am they "mistrusting science"? 10%? 5%? 1%?

That's actually an interesting question, I think. I certainly don't have a great answer as to how to draw the line. At least one can make a confident declaration at 0%. But the easy answers beyond that don't work, because there isn't an obvious algorithm that says how to convert collections of scientific papers into truth.

I myself have had some "big bets" out on major sciences being wrong for a while now, and at least one of them has metaphorically paid off; I've had a marker on "the dominant nutritional science of the day is majorly wrong" for about 13 years now. That would be the dominant nutritional science of the 1990s, with "excessive fat is the cause of obesity" being the primary claim, along with assorted other things. That the 1990s was wrong seems to be becoming the dominant position now at just about the maximum rate it can without anyone having to ever admit they were wrong. (Note that as a negation, I'm not claiming I did or do know what is the correct theory, just that the dominant one was wrong.) Was I "mistrusting science"? There were some scientists who led me in that direction, after all. If I was "mistrusting science", was that bad? Because it apparently wasn't very trustworthy anyhow. It is all-but-100% likely that some major fields of science today are just as wrong. What are they? I've got some thoughts but I can't prove them.

The correct relationship between the public and science is a legitimately difficult problem. It is certainly tempting for establishment (of whatever the appropriate establishment is) scientists to just yell at the public for not believing this or that element of their establishment position, but we must balance this against the fact that we have a looooot of history of establishment scientists being wrong, with at times quite significant consequences. Blind trust would be misplaced. Informed trust is an awfully tall bar. It's a hard problem.

Re:The Mistrust of Science by internaut on Saturday June 11, 2016 @03:43PM (#11884991)
> I myself have had some "big bets" out on major sciences being wrong for a while now, and at least one of them has metaphorically paid off;

What about a prediction market for science?

I think many insiders know some of the stuff is bunk but the public doesn't have the time or motivation to be able to make fine grained decisions about the validity of a particular line of research.

Prediction markets would make public policy decisions about investment in science more, ah, scientific perhaps.

My intuition is that 'good talkers' are getting funding over 'good walkers'. It is legitimately hard to generate informed trust and one wonders if it is even a worthwhile thing to make the attempt when advertising works so effectively. I would like to see the affects of applying a universal basic income just to scientists, because I think a reasonable chunk of the bullshiters would be filtered out.

Re:The Mistrust of Science by jerf on Sunday June 12, 2016 @11:51AM (#11888608)
A prediction market needs to have very concrete events that can be unambiguously paid out. I don't think we have one for science. If we did have such a metric for "when a scientist was correct", we could just use it directly. It isn't that useful for a prediction market to only work on multi-decade bets, plus one would have to consider the second-order effect of giving the original consensus position an even bigger monetary stake in maintaining dominance.
Re:The Mistrust of Science by Alex3917 on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:30PM (#11884345)
> then on what basis do you attack the public

Am I doing this? FWIW though, I think it's generally a pretty big red flag when people make decisions without being familiar with the relevant research that exists.

Re:The Mistrust of Science by jerf on Sunday June 12, 2016 @11:49AM (#11888598)
That was a reference to the original article, sorry.