Teaching is absolutely a thankless job in the actual work. Students are constantly disrupting class, calling teachers names, threatening teachers and other students. Administrators blame teachers for their students' behavior. Parents routinely shout at, insult, and threaten teachers. Other teachers are often hostile. Any perceived glory in teaching is just whitewashing the real nature of the job (kind of like military service -- lots of talk about glory and honor, but immense disrespect in day to day experiences).
"Dedicated public servants" is almost a pejorative euphemism at this point.
Some simple arithmetic: given that teachers are excluded from that study if they work less than 35 hours, we discover at most (38.5-35)/(K-35) % of teachers work K hours/week. (This is based on the extreme case of x% of teachers working K hours, 1-x% working 35 hours.) So if 50 hours/week is "good", then at most 23% of teachers are good.
As for your subjective opinions about "thankless", what evidence - if any - would cause you to change your belief?
I know several teachers. The burden of proof would be on you to demonstrate that teaching is a higher status profession with endlessly respectful and eager students.
Saying that contract hours are the actual hours a teacher works is at best disingenuous. It's absolute bullshit.
Most likely you are simply mistaken/lying about the amount of hours you worked. Don't worry - you are in good company. Most people routinely give high numbers for how much they work "usually", as compared to how much they worked last week.
If you don't get good returns your first couple of years, you'll likely be out permanently. A couple of bad years on a 20 year trading record, you might be fine. Then again, Alex's sources all note that VAM stabilizes after a number of years (between 3 and 5). So long term teachers should be fine too.
Similarly for salespeople. Like it or not, getting a professional evaluation based on a noisy objective measurement is nothing special. It happens in many professions - why should teachers be protected?
Also, I didn't realize 38.5 hours/week, 9 months/year was "unconscionable".
http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2008/03/art4full.pdf
Also, teaching is not "thankless". Teachers are given a high degree of respect - #2 below nurses, in terms of ethics/honesty.
http://www.gallup.com/file/poll/166364/Honesty_and_Ethics_of...
In terms of competence and warmth teachers also rank near the top on both axes.
http://www.pnas.org/content/111/Supplement_4/13593.abstract?...
Or just note the typical language used to describe them, e.g. "dedicated public servants".
What makes you think teaching is "thankless"?
I've never heard of anyone denying the pigeon hole principle in that context (or any context), but straw men are a very effective rhetorical device.
Go listen to discussions of housing in SF.