Re:Medieval Iceland and the Absence of Government
by esspem on Saturday March 13, 2010 @04:15AM
(#1188727)
Have you ever seen a working liberal democracy before US? :)
That kind of argument doesn't work for proving impossibility.
Life without violence from government (taxes) is certainly possible. In 19th century US government spendings were only 2% from GDP. Such amount can be collected with charity without force.
Re:Medieval Iceland and the Absence of Government
by anigbrowl on Saturday March 13, 2010 @04:35AM
(#1188741)
Of course, in the 19th century the continental US wasn't densely settled and shooting the natives was considered reasonable under many circumstances. Get real, any country in the world that found itself with vast tracts of fertile land more or less free for the taking would have a fabulous GDP - budget ratio too.
Iceland is a pretty unique case: everyone there is pretty much everyone else’s cousin, and they’re on an island. They look the same, have roughly the same beliefs, etc. etc. And I’m still far from convinced that medieval Iceland was really so utopic.
I'm thinking of Sparta though, which was by many accounts pretty culturally uniform and egalitarian/meritocratic, at least for citizens.
* * *
I think the best analysis I know is still Tocqueville’s Democracy in America. I also recommend The Federalist Papers, particularly Nos. 10 and 51, for a pragmatic solution to these kinds of problems, based on the decades of first-hand experience some smart blokes like Madison and Jefferson had trying to run fledgling democratic states. (And Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy is probably worth a read too.)
For a more literary exploration, read some Balzac novels: early 19th century France was the beginning of the cross-over from aristocracy to bourgeoisie, and rapidly growing cities quickly accumulated bureaucracies.