Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by tptacek on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:47PM
(#11881096)
How exactly does putting a provision in a treaty make it harder to repeal? The same actions that ratify the treaty (for instance, passing an enabling domestic law) can be used to break it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by proksoup on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:55PM
(#11881148)
Because it's no longer as simple as repealing/passing a domestic law but in addition to that becomes an issue of reneging on an agreement with other nations. In practice maybe we don't respect treaties very much, but it does seem to be an additional barrier, at least in the public discourse about what laws to repeal/pass.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by iofj on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:21PM
(#11881869)
This is the theory that the EU tries to push on it's member states. They have accepted that international treaties carry greater weight than the local laws and even the constitution of the local countries :
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supremacy_(European_Union_law)
As to whether it applies to all treaties or just the EU ones, ... good question. In practice courts haven't really followed it.
Also, just as a data point, I've been working in Brussels for close to 20 years now and seen the evolution. I work as a consultant, so it has been a mixed bag for me. However, for just about everyone else, workers, middle class, business owners, ... it has been a consistently worsening disaster.
Having regularly worked for the EU commission, let me tell you this : any idea you may have that this organization has anything but their own economic interests at heart can be cured by chatting with one of them for 5 minutes.
Re:Google endorses the Trans-Pacific Partnership
by pzone on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:54PM
(#11881136)
It's like how the US is slightly less likely to unilaterally legalize marijuana at the federal level, it is signatory to several UN treaties which forbid it from doing so.