Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction
by acdha on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:40PM
(#11880709)
I keep coming back to a very simple policy: disclosure. When the ACLU pays for lawyers, it's not a secret and e.g. a judge, government official, etc. making decisions about the case does so with full knowledge of who's backing it.
As with campaign finance, this has two benefits: it avoids trying to enumerate all of the ways someone might try to game the system and it addresses free speech concerns by simply requiring attribution in an area where there's a strong public interest.
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction
by selimthegrim on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:38PM
(#11881729)
Oh really, so then you'd be OK with throwing out the case law for cases like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAACP_v._Button and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAACP_v._Alabama?
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction
by acdha on Saturday June 11, 2016 @12:00AM
(#11881990)
In neither case was the NAACP's involvement concealed so I assume you're switching to the question of whether this goes more than one level deep to include the membership lists. That's a good question – it would be interesting to see how a modern court would rule on something like setting minimum thresholds, or how many more options a state-level attacker has now to build that kind of list without permission.
Re:Gawker Files for Bankruptcy, Will Be Put Up for Auction
by CPLX on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:07PM
(#11880031)
That would be fine. The hypothetical billionaire non-profit would have disclosure rules, and the judge could determine if their charter was sufficiently related to be able to weigh in. This isn't actually all that complicated, we do it for amicus filings all the time.
Because if your framework becomes "non-profit that publicly reports spending is okay," what's to stop a billionaire from donating millions to their own non-profit, governed by a bunch of their "elected" friends (membership fee = $1M)? Now you can expect a bunch of lawsuits over that question!