Re:Medieval Iceland and the Absence of Government
by anigbrowl on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:04PM
(#1187911)
Well it took ~200 years from when they first decided to adopt Christianity to the collapse of the commonwealth (if http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Iceland#Commonwealth... is to be believed). I suspect the tiny population was a much bigger factor. The article doesn't even address the question of population size or density and the idea that you can freely scale up from a small agrarian society is a rather big assumption.
Mr Whiston mentions slavery in the context of working off a debt, implying that slavery was only a temporary condition, but in fact it seems to have been institutionalized in early Icelandic society. So I suppose this system is good if you are born into a family of free farmers, but if you happen to be the offspring of a slave you might not think it was such a hot proposition.
He makes much of the fact that the poor could sell their right of retribution to a chieftain with the economic or military wherewithal to enforce such a claim, but I fail to see how this is very different from a law firm taking a case on a contingency basis if they think there's clear evidence of a tort having been committed and the chance of a sufficient payout.
Mr Whiston mentions slavery in the context of working off a debt, implying that slavery was only a temporary condition, but in fact it seems to have been institutionalized in early Icelandic society. So I suppose this system is good if you are born into a family of free farmers, but if you happen to be the offspring of a slave you might not think it was such a hot proposition.
He makes much of the fact that the poor could sell their right of retribution to a chieftain with the economic or military wherewithal to enforce such a claim, but I fail to see how this is very different from a law firm taking a case on a contingency basis if they think there's clear evidence of a tort having been committed and the chance of a sufficient payout.