Re:Slack Connectivity Issues
by DanielStraight on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:13PM
(#11878565)
Right. People are more than happy to use free, open source, standardized, distributed, self-owned software and services... when that software and those services offer the best solution for their needs. There's only so much ease of use and functionality people can be realistically expected to trade away.
Yeah, Slack is down... but the gains made from using it outweigh the pain of having to deal with the failure. Improve the less proprietary options to where this isn't true anymore and people will stop using the more proprietary options.
There are always trade-offs, and expecting people not to make them is unrealistic.
The question I have is why aren't industry leaders contributing to these specs? Why isn't Slack sending RFCs to improve IRC?
Re:Slack Connectivity Issues
by skywhopper on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:14PM
(#11878583)
What benefit would it be to Slack to publish their protocols? Or to IRC to know about them? I think the chances are extremely slim that IRC could be improved by knowing how Slack works. Slack is not a technical marvel with mysterious underpinnings. It's a centralized chat service with a pretty interface, simple clients, and (the secret sauce that won them all the converts) seamless integrations with pretty much every other open or semi-open service out there.
IRC would benefit simply by having someone that's actually working to improve it. It doesn't matter if the improvements are superficial; humans are superficial, that stuff matter a lot.
There is no economic model to support free/open systems and standards. It's in nobody's best interest.
Slack's business is built on free/open standards, they don't exist without http and html. Asking them to contribute in their area of expertise is not asking a lot.
Not just that, none of the current web economy exists without linux and gnu and other free/libre software.
Re:Slack Connectivity Issues
by aaronbrethorst on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:11PM
(#11878547)
Why would they want to? Improving IRC does nothing to benefit Slack.
Re:Slack Connectivity Issues
by chrisfosterelli on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:07PM
(#11878510)
This is a very good point. Many people I know stopped using IRC quite a bit before they ever started using Slack.
I stopped using both USENET and IRC long before any of these alternatives appeared.