Re:Ask HN: Do I have a right to know who gave me a bad refer...
by brudgers on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:36AM
(#11875898)
1. For legal rights under New York Sate employment law, it might be best to talk to an attorney.
2. There is what the reference said. What the firm told told the headhunter and what the headhunter said. The information is third hand.
3. If there were multiple channels into the firm, then information could have come from one of their networks independently of the provided references.
4. Because the list of past employers are as much references as personal references, it could have been anyone at a former employer who was indifferent and contact could have been outside formal HR channels.
5. The headhunter could have formed the opinion on their own and withdrawn your candidacy. The headhunter could have been unable to reach favorable terms with the company regarding their compensation. Someone more appealing to the headhunter could have come along. The job might not really exist. It might have been filled.
Sure, not getting a job kinda sucks. It's probably not worth the risk of collateral damage due to insufficient or inaccurate information. Or both.
2. There is what the reference said. What the firm told told the headhunter and what the headhunter said. The information is third hand.
3. If there were multiple channels into the firm, then information could have come from one of their networks independently of the provided references.
4. Because the list of past employers are as much references as personal references, it could have been anyone at a former employer who was indifferent and contact could have been outside formal HR channels.
5. The headhunter could have formed the opinion on their own and withdrawn your candidacy. The headhunter could have been unable to reach favorable terms with the company regarding their compensation. Someone more appealing to the headhunter could have come along. The job might not really exist. It might have been filled.
Sure, not getting a job kinda sucks. It's probably not worth the risk of collateral damage due to insufficient or inaccurate information. Or both.
Good luck.