News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by ajross on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:26PM (#1187547)
I'd love to see some modern testing results on that, honestly. The idea of "flicking" the mouse to the corner of the screen made sense on a 512x348 Mac Plus desktop. It doesn't seem as appropriate on a 1920x1080 monster, where generally nothing is maximized anyway. And with a touchpad you can't do it at all.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by jwecker on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:57PM (#1187776)
I may have confused the issue. It's not about the flick of the mouse- it's about not having to aim (e.g., can you perform this action using your peripheral vision?). It sounds like you've become accustomed to aiming at everything and therefore don't see what the big deal is. Obviously the designers in question feel as you do, so it's certainly widespread.

As for the research, just to further clarify- they rigged a mac so that there was a second monitor above the first monitor (and above the main mac menu) that the mouse pointer could move to. When mac users sat down to use it, even knowing exactly what was going on, they consistently overshot the menu by an average of half a screen. I'd be highly surprised if resolution was even minimally relevant.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by DougBTX on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:12PM (#1187671)
You're neglecting pointer acceleration, which applies for touchpads too.

If yours is anything like mine, try this: position your mouse to the far left of the screen; quickly swipe across the touch pad from left to right. Your pointer should reach the far right hand side of the screen. Now swipe ever so slowly from right to left, your pointer might get about a quarter of the way across the screen.

Once you consider acceleration (eg, the further you try to move, the faster you are moving when you get there), Fitt's law is more, not less, important on a big screen.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by cracki on Saturday March 13, 2010 @12:17AM (#1188527)
i disabled acceleration, and i suspect many others do.

i tried several times to get used to it. it's just not predictable enough for me. hitting or missing a target just because i was too fast or slow, sounds useless to me.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by elblanco on Sunday March 14, 2010 @10:26AM (#1190690)
The acceleration curve on macs is horribly horribly broken. There's a bunch of utilities to fix it or turn it off because strangely you can't do it yourself.