News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by rajadigopula on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:19AM (#11874988)
'I want teachers and parents to recognize that when you do see unusual talent, instead of demanding that these people have certain test scores, let’s find a way to help nurture them. Because I think humanity needs it. I think these are the lessons we learn from Ramanujan.'

So well said, can't even comment on the line!

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by nxzero on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:43AM (#11875451)
Everyone has a talent, only a matter of finding it.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:03AM (#11875514)
Definitely not true. That is such a feel-good, sweeping generalization with no evidence that says nothing and helps no one.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by jernfrost on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:35AM (#11876626)
I think you are seeing this in a the glass is half empty kind of way. I am assuming you think that everybody is really good at something special. Better than most people.

I don't think about it that way. My inspiration came from reading the Undercover Economist, where he starts by admitting that there are lots of people who would have written that book much better than him. However nobody has infinite time. They can't do everything. That is the key insight of the concept of comparative advantage. You do what you are best at even if everybody else is better than you at that thing. It doesn't matter because if their comparative advantage is in a different area, they are better off doing that.

So the glass is half full way of reading everybody is talented at something, simply means everybody is better at some things than other things. You might be a poor mathematician and a poor writer. But if you are a better mathematician than writer, then that is probably what you should do.

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:45AM (#11876683)
You raise a good point, and CA is the reason why trading with other nations is a good idea (econ101). I should have made my point clearer. I'm not trying to take the glass is half empty positon. I wanted to point out that such statement places all the burden on the individual without recognizing the system that needs to assist in fostering and discovering talent.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by porFavor on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:01PM (#11877802)
The current public school system is based on the British Colonial model. At the time the British empire spanned the globe there was no robust method of immediate mass communication. So, how was the Empire going to ensure that marching orders were carried out as they were handed down?

Create cogs. Everyone learned the same thing everywhere. And you learned in an environment that stressed the immediacy of execution. The Empire didn't want its citizens thinking about whether or not to follow an order in the middle of a battle. The citizen was needed to simply do as told, now.

As a result there was standardization of curriculum and an expectation of rote learning, not critical analysis and the exercise of judgment.

Contrast that with our current environment.

Products have long lead times. Skype. A massive percent of our GDP is spent on things that we didn't even know we needed or wanted. Many of the things that we rely on everyday are the product of discovery rather than directives.

So, when the person said everyone has a talent, I take that to mean, we can each bring something to the table. Diversity of thought. Diversity of experience. And that, is definitely true.

What is not true, what is arbitrary, is that there is some defined set of talents that have value and a person either masters one or more of these talents or, if they don't, they have no talent. That point of view is ignorant and counterproductive for both individuals and communities.

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:31PM (#11878135)
It is my fault for not being clear. I was making fun of the bumper-sticker, oversimplified statement. I have no quarrel with the idea that everyone has something unique to bring to the table. Also I was upset by the fact that it seemed to put all the burden on the individual, when in reality discovery and fostering of talent is as much a job of the society.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by porFavor on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:03PM (#11878475)
"it seemed to put all the burden on the individual, when in reality discovery and fostering of talent is as much a job of the society"

Word.

Not sure how I feel about this sentiment applied to the original comment. But, 100% agree with the sentiment generally speaking.

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by thegp on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:11AM (#11875776)
As opposed to the helpful, precise and empirically corroborated statement that NOT everybody has a talent, no matter how hard they look?
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:39AM (#11876650)
The word used was "everyone". All I have to do is point to a bum on the street and the original statement is false. I just wanted to make a point that such statement places all the burden on the individual, without acknolwedging the systems at play in fostering and developing talent.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by wfo on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:23PM (#11877519)
No, this isn't how proof works. All you have to do is find a bum, and definitively prove that he has no talent at anything, even things he has never been exposed to, even things that have fallen out of fashion, even things that have yet to be invented.

Go ahead, get started, I'll wait. If you could please do this with many bums, the world would thank you -- every inevitable failure will make the world a better place.

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:45PM (#11877699)
What good is talent if you can't exercise it? Also you clearly do not get the point of my rebuttal. Also why so hostile?
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by wfo on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:57PM (#11877777)
I'm not sure why it's so important to you to push the notion that some people just simply are not good at anything (and of course you use, as an example, a homeless person -- obviously they must be talentless, yes, otherwise they would be successful like us?).

"Everyone has a talent, it's just a matter of finding it" -- the point you are dismissively hostile towards is a positive one which is essentially irrefutable. It doesn't claim talent is "any good" or that it can easily be exercised. It's suggesting everyone has worth and something to offer. I don't know why you are so opposed to accepting something like that. The hostility here isn't mine.

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:26PM (#11878058)
If you read my second sentence "I just wanted to make a point that such statement places all the burden on the individual, without acknolwedging the systems at play in fostering and developing talent", you would know that we hold the same position. The point I am making is not that some are talented and some are not (only idiots would believe in fully meritocratic outcomes), but that the burden of seemingly "untalented" people lies with the society as much as it does with the individual, and the original bumper-sticker statement does not acknowledge that complexity and power dynamic. I have no hostility.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by psbp on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:12AM (#11876091)
*Everybody potentially has a talent that they should attempt to find.

Is everyone happy now?

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by nibs on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:14AM (#11876928)
Everyone is still in the gene pool for a reason.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:35AM (#11877100)
Having no talent and not being worthy of being in the gene pool are not the same thing.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by nibs on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:02PM (#11878465)
I did not refer to whether people are worthy of being in the gene pool, you assumed. What I mean is that everyone who is still in the gene pool is still in it for a reason. Sometimes people have talent, sometimes people don't have talent. One should not feel bad for not having talent, maybe talent is not what got you here. Maybe you have other things to offer, things that could not really be considered a talent.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by plaidturtle on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:38PM (#11878802)
I agree that talent is not be-all and end-all. I did not mean that with my comment.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by gens on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:51PM (#11877737)
Please don't separate children based on what you perceive their intelligence to be.
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by kauffj on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:42PM (#11878267)
Really? What's the alternative? Have really smart kids suffer through lessons that are menial to them?

I was lucky enough to be in a school that had lots of programs for gifted kids and let them do their own work or work in small groups among themselves. Those moments were by far the brightest of my compulsory education.

Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by gens on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:16PM (#11879647)
I'm glad for you
Re:Inspired by Genius: How a Mathematician Found His Way by b_emery on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:01PM (#11879982)
Rather, separate children based on what you perceive their needs to be.