News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Too Many Knobs by chillaxtian on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:46AM (#11874677)
> a significant percentage (up to 48.5%) of configuration issues are about users' difficulties in finding or setting the parameters to obtain the intended system behavior

this is the important bit to me.

i don't like using software that feels like it could fall over because i turned the wrong combination of knobs the developer didn't anticipate.

opinionated, fixed configuration is a nicer experience than an app that can do anything, if you bend it to your will.

Re:Too Many Knobs by TeMPOraL on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:04AM (#11875138)
The thing is - some of us want software not for "experience", but for its utility. If I want "experience", I can go to a theme park or play a video game. I expect my software to help me achieve my goals faster and more efficiently, or to at least eliminate clutter in my life.

Also, nothing really prevents one from having the settings hidden in the "advanced" menu. It's not either/or.

Re:Too Many Knobs by Hondor on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:43AM (#11875659)
Nobody ever says they want fewer options, but that's because it's never such a pressing issue as not having the one you want.

In a program I develop, I sometimes remove an option and people complain, then it turns out they were randomly tweaking that option to try to solve some problems that it was never going to solve in the first place. They just liked the feeling of being able to control _something_. So those are cases of bad options that should have been removed because they made it harder for people. People just can't help but try changing settings when something doesn't work, and hiding them in an "advanced" menu doesn't deter them. That's where all the most powerful settings are afertall! It encourages frustrating time wasting.

Re:Too Many Knobs by red_admiral on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:02AM (#11875323)
Or a configuration file with proper documentation.
Re:Too Many Knobs by jasonlotito on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:34AM (#11876204)
> opinionated, fixed configuration is a nicer experience

Even when those opinions are wrong?

Re:Too Many Knobs by Too on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:00AM (#11882581)
Compiz is the perfect example of this, the defaults are broken, there are thousands of options with no constraints, if you change one option to fix the broken default you will be guaranteed to break some other feature.