You could just 'Right Click->Open in Incognito' instead of manually copying the URL, at least in Chrome.
Firefox and Pale Moon both have "Open Link in New Private Window".
IE has some kind of private browsing option as well, but I don't know what would be the equivalent way to invoke it.
History is important, but the site is called "ruinmysearchhistory.com". I visit websites I know with my normal window, the rest is mostly in incognito and if it's something I want to remember, I'll make sure to include it (i.e: visit it in normal mode, Evernote, Bookmarks, email to myself, etc).