Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by nfnaaron on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:27PM
(#1187392)
I think bureaucracy had little to do with it. As I recall, the first Netflix contest did indeed expose private, and sometimes embarrassing, information.
This was a privacy issue, and something legitimate to address.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by sh1mmer on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:18PM
(#1187525)
Right, but I find it astonishing that it was necessary to cancel the competition altogether.
I find it surprising that there wasn't a middle-ground which anonymized or didn't include personally identifying information.
I feel the lack of a middle-ground is probably due to the lawsuit plaintiffs refusing to back down (presumably for financial gain) and thus causing Netflix to hedge their risk.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by nlabs on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:30PM
(#1187403)
privacy issues dont necessarily need to be dealt with by lawsuits. Most lawsuits are about money.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by nfnaaron on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:36PM
(#1187416)
Not to quibble, but lawsuits are also not bureaucracy.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by tbgvi on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:53PM
(#1187464)
Good point, was at a loss for the right word when I commented.
This kind of behavior by lawyers is just like patent trolling and I couldn't pinpoint a word for that. Maybe privacy trolling? The lawyers are the same ones that sued Facebook for Beacon.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by wingo on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:11PM
(#1187511)
While it's not entirely the same situation, perhaps you should read up on the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_search_data_scandal.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by mhb on Friday March 12, 2010 @10:57PM
(#1188431)
why doesn't Netflix have people opt-in to have their data anonymized and used for this purpose?
Selection bias?
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by ntoshev on Saturday March 13, 2010 @03:45AM
(#1188698)
Selection bias would mean people who opt in get better recommendations... sounds like a good incentive and a virtuous circle to me.
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by nlabs on Saturday March 13, 2010 @04:43AM
(#1188744)
selection bias would only be a concern if you were trying make inference on all netflix customers (not just the ones that opt-in).
Re:Netflix Prize 2 Cancelled Due to a Lawsuit and FTC Inquiry
by tel on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:50PM
(#1187451)
It breaks simple random sampling meaning that you're optimizing purely for some unknown subset. That becomes a problem when someone someone realizes that Netflix is spending millions of dollars to have a recommendation engine that ends up being racist.
And I agree with one of the comments on that post - why doesn't Netflix have people opt-in to have their data anonymized and used for this purpose?
Edit: replaced bureaucracy with lawsuits