News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by jrockway on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:12PM (#1187345)
Wow... if only the window manager was a separate program or something... then you could just run the one that you like instead of the default one.

Oh, you mean that's true? Oh...

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by cookiecaper on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:17PM (#1187360)
Good defaults are crucial to the success of a platform. Ubuntu is going for mainstream adoption. The mainstream wants their computers to "just work". They don't want to have to change themes or window managers, they just want the buttons to live where they're expected.

Even if the users were willing to change the WM for the button position, almost no user knows how to change the WM, and it probably necessitates editing .desktop files or .xinitrc or something (unless you use something like fusion-icon to control it, which might be reasonable but is still extra configuration).

Furthermore, this is custom to that theme. Any other Metacity theme has the buttons on the right, so they'd just have to change the theme, not the WM, to get the buttons where desired.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by pyre on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:07PM (#1187658)
> They don't want to have to change themes or window managers, they just want the buttons to live where they're expected.

By this reasoning no one on Windows would ever switch to OSX.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by DougBTX on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:19PM (#1187699)
At least OSX and Windows both put the close button in a corner, this theme puts it between the maximise button and the window title. I've never seen another OS put it in such a strange position.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by pyre on Sunday March 14, 2010 @07:45PM (#1191588)
How does that negate my statement? Normal people don't look for things like, "Is the close button on the outside of the window?" Are you really going to tell me that the only reason that people tolerate a switch from Windows to MacOS X is because the close-window button is still towards the outside of the window even though the buttons are on the opposite side?
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by cookiecaper on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:24PM (#1188184)
Sometimes frustration with one system can cause one to tolerate the learning curve on a new one.

There are some people who don't mind learning things about their computers but in my experience they are pretty rare as a segment of the whole population.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by flogic on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:25PM (#1187383)
That's fine unless you're billing yourself as a user friendly Linux. Personally I think the issue of mis-clicking while going for the file menu would be infuriating.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by jrockway on Friday March 12, 2010 @01:56PM (#1187473)
Most users care more about looks than functionality, and not even much about that. People still use Windows XP and are perfectly happy, right?

I also like how people invent mysterious "other people" and "average users" to use as arguments when they don't like something. The average user also thinks that technique is suspect. Why not just say, "I wish they didn't change this" instead of saying, "the average user is too clumsy to use this".

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by flogic on Friday March 12, 2010 @04:07PM (#1187806)
My biggest concern here would be going for the "Edit" menu and hitting "Close" by accident. I know I miss the item I'm aiming for from time to time.

Otherwise I could careless, people learned to use Hotmail, Facebook, and eBay just fine.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by jrockway on Friday March 12, 2010 @08:06PM (#1188240)
I wish I could see a graph of the number of votes on this post over time. I've looked at it a few times today; at one point it was 5, now it's -3.