News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by barrkel on Friday March 12, 2010 @12:18PM (#1187167)
It's a weakness of all centralized software construction mechanisms that change chosen by a handful of people can end up thrust unwillingly on large crowds. It's not like casual users can fork Ubuntu simply because they dislike the window layout.

But there are some pathologies that seem endemic to open source. A revealing comment by one of the bug shepherds on the relevant bug[1] says "Change is always good , if there is a good reason to change". I think this is plainly false: change doesn't just need good reasons, it needs excellent reasons, because change by itself has such high costs.

Open source is often too open to change for its own sake, and often lacks consideration for the maintenance costs of new functionality. To take the on-topic example of OS changes, it was viable for XP users to completely skip Vista, and continue to use the old OS, over a period of nearly 10 years, without issues of incompatibility. Try doing the same with a typical Linux distro, and you'll find your apt-get (or equivalent) will pull in all sorts of dependencies that you may or may not desire if you want to use the latest software.

[1] https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/bugs/532633

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by SwellJoe on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:05PM (#1187500)
To take the on-topic example of OS changes, it was viable for XP users to completely skip Vista, and continue to use the old OS, over a period of nearly 10 years, without issues of incompatibility. Try doing the same with a typical Linux distro, and you'll find your apt-get (or equivalent) will pull in all sorts of dependencies that you may or may not desire if you want to use the latest software.

You've made a mistake in your Linux distro selection, if lifecycle in a priority (and for me, it usually is). RHEL (and thus, CentOS) has a seven year update cycle. During that period they will never "pull in all sorts of dependencies you may or may not desire". It is a stable platform and it remains the same throughout its lifecycle. If you prefer apt-based distros, Ubuntu LTS has a five year lifecycle. Debian tends to be about 3-4 years, but is based on the development of the next revision rather than a stated lifecycle, as far as I know (so if Debian develops faster, you have to upgrade faster).

That said, I suppose one could argue that on older stable Linux distros, one might have to add some dependencies from outside of the core OS in order to run super new stuff...though I rarely find things that won't build against the libraries available on CentOS 5 or Ubuntu 8.04LTS. Some developer tools move really fast, as do some of the new-fangled Gnome or KDE user applications, but mostly I never notice that the OS is a couple years old.

So, yes, Open Source does change faster, but there are very easy ways to opt out of the rapid release cycle for systems that need stability (like servers). I can't tell you the number of folks I've met over the years who've started out with Fedora or Ubuntu, only to figure out that upgrading every 12-18 months is stressful and unproductive, and moved to a more predictable distro, even though it has older packages.

In short, you have a choice about how long you can use a Linux distro safely and productively. You can prioritize for the latest and greatest or you can prioritize stability and predictability.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by jfager on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:28PM (#1187555)
One of the most confusing parts about this switch, to me, was that it immediately precedes an LTS release. Why would you spring experimental changes right before the release you're calling 'stable' and committing to for 5 years? I was under the impression that LTS was supposed to be the distillation of all the new features that were embraced or rejected during the wild and crazy intermediate releases.

The actual change isn't that big of a deal. It's pretty easy to fix, and it would have been fine in a minor release with plenty of lead time before it became 'official', just to try it out. The big deal is that this reveals a broken management and release process, and comes across as a serious trust breaker.

Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by SwellJoe on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:13PM (#1188159)
Ubuntu has a long history of making dumb little changes without warning and then committing to them against all reason. I don't know if they've fixed it yet, or not, but my favorite is when they broke the Apache configuration file by adding shell variables to it (thus making it it unparse-able by everything other than Ubuntu scripts; the Apache standard tools can't parse the Ubuntu configuration file without pre-processing, for an example of how absurd this decision was). All this breakage was caused just because someone was too lazy to parse out a few different types of variables from the existing configuration file syntax (I looked it up, and the comment about this in the changelog was that parsing it wasn't possible; despite the fact that numerous, probably hundreds, of applications and scripts do parse it correctly). The Ubuntu developer culture of superiority and self-importance is quite trying at times.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by leif on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:15PM (#1187516)
slaaaaaaaaaaackwaaaaaaaaaaaare ;)
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by SwellJoe on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:15PM (#1188166)
No package management? No thanks.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by Xurinos on Friday March 12, 2010 @12:25PM (#1187184)
Isn't this really a weakness of this system's abstraction? This appearance decision is just a skin layer. Rather than thrust it upon people, it could just be the default skin/view/appearance/theme, and there would be ways for contributors to submit additional themes that smoothly plug into the system. Don't like the buttons on the left? Use this other theme instead, which is mostly the same but with this exception.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by barrkel on Friday March 12, 2010 @12:53PM (#1187279)
Yes, there's no problem that can't be solved with another layer of indirection, etc. But making things configurable has its own costs, which are not trivial.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by jmillikin on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:11PM (#1188157)
It's a weakness in the user interface. The preference to control button placement isn't exposed in the Appearance applet, so the only way to change it is to set a gconf preference.
Re:It’s time to fix the window controls (ubuntu 10.04) by Elepsis on Friday March 12, 2010 @10:24PM (#1188398)
An interesting contrast: One of the Windows Experience Principles introduced for Windows 7 is "Change is bad, unless it's great."