Here's the full, 24-minute 911 call audio. Does that sound like genuine panic to you? How would someone who doesn't know how to stop a car have any idea if their "brakes are almost burned"? http://jalopnik.com/5489553/runaway-prius-911-tape-im-over-9...
The driver filed for bankruptcy in 2008, and still has $700,000 in debt. http://jalopnik.com/5491101/did-bankrupt-runaway-prius-drive...
There's significant reason to suspect this guy may have attempted a pretty blatant cash grab.
Regardless, I think the Corolla is the only Toyota sedan that still has rear-drums. I believe all others (maybe barring the bottom-rung Camry) are 4-wheel discs. The brake systems on Lexuses are also significantly beefier (though nowhere near sports car territory). C&D did tests with Mustang GT500s -- which while having beefier brake packages, aren't anything compared to normal supercars and high-end sports cars -- had no problem stopping a 500HP engine from 120mph while maintaining wide-open-throttle. Sure, it took some distance, but it definitely stopped. My point is, if you step on the brake pedal and don't release, ANY car that is properly maintained will stop.
On a side note, I recently had a stuck accelerator less than a week ago. (No it isn't a Toyota) Since I drive a manual transmission, I just quickly clutched and shifted to neutral. The engine redlined a bit before I killed it, which isn't good, but no serious harm to anyone or machine as far as I can tell. I coasted to a stop and then pulled the gas pedal from the floor with my hand. The weird thing is, after your comment just now I was trying to remember whether I tried to apply the brakes and I don't remember. It is cliche, but it "happened so fast," haha.
Not to sound like a jerk, but if you're too panicked to do this, maybe you shouldn't be piloting a several thousand pound piece of steel around...
Also, this supports my belief that every driver should have to know how to drive a vehicle with a manual-shift gearbox. Shifting into neutral would probably happen without much of a second thought for somebody who normally drives a stickshift.