News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by patio11 on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:01AM (#1186024)
Anonymizing can be implemented by simply randomizing usernames, but in a way that keeps users uniquely identified in a scope of a single discussion.

I think you underestimate the ability of people to identify others based on what English teachers call their "voice". I mean, here's a test you can do in forty-five seconds in Ruby or your language of choice: grab the RSS feeds from searchyc.com for pg and any other user you want to play the game with, have your script randomly spit out a recent post from one of the two lists, see if you can guess who said it. This turns out to be really, really easy, particularly for good writers who one spends a lot of time reading. (You can do this with Bayesian classification, too. In the "Pick who wrote this out of two possibilities for which there are many samples" case it's like taking candy from a baby in terms of classification tasks.)

Also, do you think you or anyone else is going to have much trouble telling who baby_rutabega_spoon is when he talks about his bingo business or ruthless_carrot_fork when he gets exasperated about password hashing?

Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by poronski on Friday March 12, 2010 @12:58PM (#1187289)
Also, do you think you or anyone else is going to have much trouble telling who baby_rutabega_spoon is when he talks about his bingo business or ruthless_carrot_fork when he gets exasperated about password hashing?

These are exceptions. I can bet that a vast majority of people here would not be able to tell even pg apart from other posters if it were not for his username.

Besides these exceptions are fine, the anonymization is not meant to target them, but rather generic blabber-mouths whose comments are floating up only because of the group upvoting.

Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by tptacek on Friday March 12, 2010 @12:38PM (#1187229)
My carrot fork is anything but ruthless, Patrick!
Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by jacquesm on Saturday March 13, 2010 @10:51PM (#1190224)
Here I was thinking he meant Colin :)
Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by tptacek on Sunday March 14, 2010 @01:37PM (#1190930)
Colin talks about things besides password hashing. That's how you can tell us apart.
Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by jacquesm on Sunday March 14, 2010 @04:11PM (#1191230)
Did you know 'ptacek' means 'little bird' in Polish ?
Re:Poll: Ask or Leaders in Top Bar? by tptacek on Saturday March 20, 2010 @11:08PM (#1207453)
It implies something worse than that in Polish, but not in Slovakia.