Anecdotally speaking, I've taken Uber quite often in Austin, as well as various cabs, and they always seemed comparable to me. In fact, if you take into account Uber's surge pricing (which cabs don't have, afaik), Uber came out more expensive on average.
Where I'm from (Toronto) the taxi rates are fixed by law and the Uber rates are publicly available on their website.
Taxi rates: $3.25 + $1.74 per km + $0.50 per minute
UberX rates: $2.50 + $0.80 per km + $0.18 per minute
It's not even close.
My house to the airport via taxi... $45-65. 30-40 minutes.
I fly 2-3x per week, thinking about putting together some expense reports to back this up... but for now you'll have to take my word. (=
That comparison is only helpful if you note how long it took for both to show up.
First of all that's not the reason Uber and lyft are popular. Secondly, most taxi company apps suck.
Yeah... thinking it through, you're right. That's spot on. I don't think that's bad, the Taxi drivers don't treat me like a human or like their neighbor, and that's more the issue. There's just a polite way that Americans are to one another, especially Texans. Taxi Drivers are extremely transparent that they are just out to make as much money from me as they can. I don't mean it as racist, but it's very jarring to be treated rudely in Texas; people are on the whole very friendly and sociable here. It's very apparent when someone isn't from here, or hasn't lived here long enough to adapt to the local customs.
Thank you for pointing out the REAL reason why Uber/Lyft are popular. It has nothing to do with convenience (a lot of taxi companies also have similar apps) and everything to do with the fact that people want to interact with those in the same socioeconomic class as them.