Re:Gay marriage: the database engineering perspective
by roundsquare on Friday March 12, 2010 @05:03AM
(#1186293)
We only permit sterile straight couples to get married to promote the illusion that marriage is about love and happiness for the married couple.
Continuing in the tradition of stating opinions that are not ours but are potentially interesting:
One could argue that at the time these laws were made, checking for sterility was impossible and is now potentially prohibitive or inaccurate as medical science improves.
Re:Gay marriage: the database engineering perspective
by yummyfajitas on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:25AM
(#1186483)
One could also argue that preventing people from participating in societal institutions for medical reasons is immoral. Another application of this idea is the belief that it is wrong to deny insurance to people who are already sick. (Again, not my opinion, but an extension of a common idea.)
Re:Gay marriage: the database engineering perspective
by raleec on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:25AM
(#1186481)
Good is a not an objective reality in this situation. The quoted argument means that if I find or create a quote saying that polygamy or gay marriage is good for children, then it's equally legitimate and logical.
Logically, marriage leads to divorce, which is commonly considered bad for children!
My point is, logic relies on facts, and I don't think any camps have reached objective consensus on those.
Re:Gay marriage: the database engineering perspective
by yummyfajitas on Friday March 12, 2010 @08:11AM
(#1186545)
Nearly all arguments about policy are based on subjective values, and those values are not shared by all. There is absolutely no set of facts which can prove "gay sex is morally wrong" or "gay sex is morally acceptable".
The most one can do is show that some more generally accepted subjective value implies the a specific subjective value. A more general argument: "any act performed in private between consenting adults is morally acceptable. This implies gay sex is OK."
(That's also a specific example of a general argument which most proponents don't actually believe. See this comment thread for an example: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=806581 )
Re:Gay marriage: the database engineering perspective
by raleec on Friday March 12, 2010 @08:19AM
(#1186555)
I'll repeat what I wrote to another statement on this thread:
Ultimately, allowed marriages are a proxy for what society at large deems "reasonable." That's why this is such an issue, and I think that most arguments otherwise, on both sides, are disingenuous.
"Marriage is an institution with the primary purpose of providing a good environment for children and their biological parents. We only permit sterile straight couples to get married to promote the illusion that marriage is about love and happiness for the married couple. Since a polygamous household is not a good environment for children, we ban polygamy."