News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by staunch on Thursday March 11, 2010 @08:43PM (#1185571)
Calacanis' fantasy all along was to own Wikipedia but fill it full of ads. He used to rant endlessly about how much money they'd make if they monetized Wikipedia. Mahalo is his attempt to make a seedier low-brow version of Wikipedia that's ad-laden. This move should not be a surprise. That's just my opinion though.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by 3dFlatLander on Thursday March 11, 2010 @10:18PM (#1185706)
Kinda off topic, but I think he's right about wikipedia serving ads. They have so many page views, they could put up a couple of image or text ads on the side and make it look very tasteful--unlike mahalo and the other ad filled pages of the internet. Expanding on that, maybe they could only serve non-profits, giving them ridiculously low click or view rates. How could Jimmy Wales not be interested in that?
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by hristov on Thursday March 11, 2010 @10:36PM (#1185728)
It would release a hornet's nest worth of issues. For example advertisers might change articles in which their ads appear in order to influence click-troughs. Then contributors will ask for a cut of the money. Then nobody will donate because they have to look at ads anyway.

Then advertisers will start demanding from their sales people that certain content be changed or taken off "or I will remove my ads."

So it should only be considered as a desperation move if their donations plummet.

Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by jimmyjim on Friday March 12, 2010 @02:43AM (#1186085)
To really think about it now, it's truly remarkable that such a powerful entity can exist in such a material world, free of spam, ads, etc. I don't think we cherish this great resource as much as we should.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by JoachimSchipper on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:24AM (#1186139)
Making money off volunteers tends to make those volunteers disappear. Restricting themselves to charity may help, but it'll be an endless debate that will hurt them a lot.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by rpledge on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:27AM (#1186487)
People still volunteer to help at the Olympics, but I suspect you're right that adding ads would cause people to leave the community
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by borism on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:58AM (#1186530)
> People still volunteer to help at the Olympics

Really!?

Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by viggity on Friday March 12, 2010 @09:26AM (#1186703)
This stuff happens all the time. I paid $200 to "volunteer" to work at the PGA Senior Open
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by borism on Friday March 12, 2010 @11:21AM (#1187004)
well, I wouldn't call this stuff volunteering - you're probably interested in some particular (sporting) event and willing to pay for a good access with your work (and maybe some money)

wikipedia editors don't get that kind of privileges relative to any random visitor, I'd argue.

Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by hobbe on Friday March 12, 2010 @03:50AM (#1186171)
I'd say they could go for pure sponsorships - just a set of logos with a link to each sponsor's homepage, under the heading "Wikipedia Gold Sponsors". Very few options to sponsor a reduced part of Wikipedia (i.e. sensible to allow on language level, not at keyword level). Probably still would make the foundation a healthy sum of money each year - many large corporations would like to be seen as good-hearted contributors to the world's largest source of free curated information.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by varaon on Friday March 12, 2010 @07:03AM (#1186444)
Even if they adopted an official policy of allowing criticism, there would still be a stigma to including criticism in articles about the sponsors.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by cj on Thursday March 11, 2010 @10:25PM (#1185712)
Non-profit with extremely low click rates is an excellent idea.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by kprobst on Thursday March 11, 2010 @11:44PM (#1185799)
Wales could put three Google text ads on the front page and finance the entire operation.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by bruceboughton on Friday March 12, 2010 @04:40AM (#1186261)
Really? My experience with Wikipedia is that topic pages are frequently the first result in Google so I don't think I've seen the homepage in at least a year.
Re:Jason Calacanis’ Backup Plan For Replacing Content: Steal... by nollidge on Friday March 12, 2010 @09:56AM (#1186779)
Personally, I never see the front page unless I'm on a new browser install and need to right-click > "Create Keyword For This Search" in the search box. But I imagine people who don't use nav-bar keywords go to the front page all the time to search for something.