News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Right to Work by btilly on Thursday March 11, 2010 @06:16PM (#1185253)
The problem with your reasoning is that we have actually have lots of historical experience with what it is like when we don't license doctors. It was awful. I'm no fan of the AMA. But I like having doctors who know basic anatomy.

On all of your reputation issues, people's judgment of the quality of doctors is almost entirely a function of their bedside manner, and not their competence. If you just go off of reputation, and reputation is based on the decisions of lay people, the result is that competent doctors get bad reputations and confident charlatans get excellent ones. And health suffers accordingly.

A similar well-documented example are public health measures. My surface impressions of a restaurant are a bad guide for whether the cook washes his hands properly after going to the bathroom. And dysentery comes through infrequently enough that you won't discover this from your neighbor getting sick until far too late. But well-constructed licensing requirements solve this problem and save lives. (In fact there is good data suggesting that public health measures like these save more lives year in and year out than all of the advances of modern medicine.)

We also know what happens with public engineering. Before licensing requirements were created, the USA averaged one random bridge collapse per week. That's pretty bad. It gets rapidly worse if you get an earthquake. I live in an earthquake prone zone, and I am a very firm supporter of having the buildings I am around and in be built to standards created by qualified engineers, then inspected by properly licensed inspectors. California is among the few areas where significant earthquakes don't tend to come with massive loss of life, and I appreciate that fact.

I could multiply examples, but the flip side of the argument does not hold. The article is correct that there are a lot of stupid licensing requirements out there. The article is correct that the motivation is often restraint of trade. The article is correct that we're often all better off without those rules. But the article is dead wrong in concluding that we're better off removing all licensing requirements.

Re:The Right to Work by timwiseman on Thursday March 11, 2010 @07:11PM (#1185378)
You make good and interesting points, but remember you can (at least hypothetically) have licensing and accreditation without the government providing it. For instance, there is no legal requirement for IT certifications, and yet there are a plethora of them, some meaningful some not but most in the industry know the difference.

Similarly, even if the government did not require a license, insurance companies would likely refuse to provide malpractice insurance for those without proper training.

I agree that when it comes to large public engineering and the creation of buildings, then there is a compelling public need to make sure minimimums are met. If a building collapses unexpectedly, likely far more people than the purchaser will be harmed and irrevocably.

But that compelling public good is far weaker in other areas that require licenses now. If I have a bad florist, only myself and the person I am bestowing the flowers on is going to be harmed at all, and only minutely then. If I have a bad lawyer, the stakes may be higher, but again only I am harmed.

Re:The Right to Work by bobbin on Thursday March 11, 2010 @06:59PM (#1185353)
I'll write a piece of an answer I gave to another person:

> Lets say we want quality control in dentistry. You like the government quality control the government gives and would like your dentists to count with their approval. I, on the other hand, think it's requirements are excessive. Most of what my dentist does is find black spots in my teeth, drill them out, and then fill the hole. This does not require 4 years of study. If I ever get to need a root canal I would need someone with more studies but until then I'd me happy with someone with less studies, maybe a certification given by the manufacturer of the equipment, I don't know.

If you like the government certification you can limit yourself only to government certificated doctors. No problem. A group of people should be able do give public approval of university courses and degrees. If you like the government that OK.

I'm just object locking people in cages when they don't comply with these regulations. The violent monopoly is the problem.

> But the article is dead wrong in concluding that we're better off removing all licensing requirements.

The key word here is requirements. Not removing all licensing. The distinction is not expressed clearly. If you don't comply with the "required" licensing they lock you in jail, or the demand money from you, and if you don't comply, then you go to jail.

Re:The Right to Work by gojomo on Thursday March 11, 2010 @08:05PM (#1185497)
The problem with your reasoning is that we have actually have lots of historical experience with what it is like when we don't license doctors. It was awful.

Yes, but lots of things were 'awful' in that same era. Science and medicine were cruder; people were less educated; people were poorer; communication options were slow and limited.

Now we know more, are richer, and have instant worldwide communication and deep searchable public databases. Lots of the old paternalism, even if once justified, can now be discarded.

But also: even the welfare gains we might think were from licensing, because they occurred after the licensing was introduced, may have instead been from the same rising wealth/standards/awareness that triggered the demand to "do something".

Consider for example the trend in workplace deaths, before and after the creation of OSHA to improve occupational safety:

http://divisionoflabour.com/archives/004409.php