The botch (which just keeps getting worse) is the forced-by-any-means upgrade; if you have an upgrade path planned, and you're in the middle of testing, having all the workstations pull the rug from under you (because "This is where you want to go today!") is, IMNSHO, borderline criminal.
In other words: We had wanted to upgrade. Within weeks. Now we're dug in the trenches, locked down and hoping we didn't miss one of the upgrade backdoors; the upgrade plan is, of course, scrapped altogether. In a sentence: COMPLETE LOSS OF TRUST.
Even if that is all true today -- and I'm expressing no view here on whether it is -- with mandatory updates there is no guarantee anything will continue to work the same way tomorrow. If there is one thing Microsoft has proved beyond any doubt over the past few months, it is that we can't trust it not to abuse Windows updates. This is why the trust issue has become a major PR problem, though I suspect many in senior management at MS are still in denial about how bad that problem really is.
" Windows 10 still phones home to Microsoft with telemetry data including an anonymous device ID, information about the type of device that's being used, and data from application crashes. That sort of data has been key to solving problems with the operating system and other applications, according to an explanation published Monday from Microsoft Corporate Vice President Terry Myerson."
[1] http://www.infoworld.com/article/2987175/microsoft-windows/m...
Microsoft has used updates to change service and update names related to Telemetry already. Some of the "tips" in the comments are also wrong, like using the hosts file to block certain domains which Telemetry services don't respect.
Unless it's a documented method from Microsoft it doesn't count. Their stated aim is that all non-Enterprise customer will take part in "Basic" telemetry. Until they change that stance, random hacks from the blogosphere are at best unreliable and at worst dangerous and give a false sense of privacy and security.
Oh, I didn't realize that we were playing a board game. No, in real life when something actually works...people can use it. The registry edit does indeed work. I've used it. Plenty of people use it. So yeah - that does too count.
Apple doesn't support HomeBrew and tons of other things that developers do on OS X, but nobody sits there and says "that doesn't count".
Linux distros don't support every single configuration that Linux users put in...but nobody says "it doesn't count".
> The spying "features" can all be disabled
I've yet to find a way to disable the telemetry on a non-enterprise system. I'd appreciate any links to instructions on how to do this.
I've had the opposite experience. The OS that's supposed to have all the drivers didn't have all the drivers and I know a ton of people who were stuck without wifi (and a few who could not even connect through ethernet), had graphics problems which basically made their OS unusable, had all sorts of performance issues (especially on small netbooks that auto upgraded), the list could just go on.
You shouldn't have to disable spyware when installing an OS. You shouldn't have to install powershell to remove candy crush (which is what you had to do when Win10 first came out). You shouldn't have to uninstall adware on a new OS. You shouldn't need an SSD and other newer/high-end hardware to run an OS, especially when other operating systems run flawlessly on low-end hardware.
Nah, Windows is a trash OS and it seems like the only people who use it are people who are forced to because of program compatibility.
I was on linux for 10+ years, and I switched to Windows after they released 10 because I was truly happy with it after trying the tech preview. The program compatibility is just a bonus. Almost all of my family uses Windows over OS X because they can't stand the weird ass intentionally hobbled UI of OSX.
Now try switching to that window with they keyboard in OS X, without using any 3rd party helpers like HyperSwitch.
You can't do it.
Also try running 2 instances of the same app in OS X. You also can't do that.
OS X is garbage compared to Windows.
The "spy on everything" and "you MUST have cloud" attitude are actual OS issues, I agree.
For myself, having used Linux since early Red Hat releases and Macs (professionally) since System 6 - I am certain that OS X and every Linux desktop are absolute garbage compared to Windows.
Anyway, to address your concerns:
> You shouldn't have to disable spyware when installing an OS.
You don't have to. Problem solved.
> You shouldn't have to install powershell to remove candy crush.
You don't have to do that either. Problem solved.
> You shouldn't have to uninstall adware on a new OS.
There is none. Problem solved.
> You shouldn't need an SSD...
You don't need one. Problem solved.
> Nah, Windows is a trash OS and it seems like the only people who use it are people who are forced to because of program compatibility.
Well, that's your opinion. I use it because it's the best. So, given that you're obviously wrong that "people only use it program compatibility [and no other reason]" we'll have to conclude that your opinion is not based on facts.
You do if you don't want to be spied on.
>You don't have to do that either. Problem solved.
You did.
http://superuser.com/questions/958562/how-do-i-remove-candy-...
>There is [no adware]. Problem solved.
I consider Candycrush is adware
>You don't need [an SSD]. Problem solved.
Well it runs terribly whithout one.
It's telemetry and it's not spying. Do you use a smartphone? If so, you are already running something that has telemetry in it.
> I consider Candycrush is adware
Who cares? Again...do you use any smartphone? Do you realize that just about every smartphone that people use has some sort of app on it that has some ads? You're making a big deal out of absolutely nothing.
> Well it runs terribly whithout [an ssd].
Well my long time experience with Windows says otherwise. You apparently don't use Windows, so how would you even know? Besides that, why would you want a non-SSD for any OS in 2016?
Indeed. I made a similar argument when Adobe went subscription-only with Creative Cloud. That move seems like a clear signal to customers that Adobe thinks locking those customers in is more valuable than whatever new features or performance improvements or bug fixes Adobe is going to offer, since if the latter were more valuable then presumably customers would have been willing to pay for a new version and choose to install it anyway.
They've done that. Every single time. That's why Windows is the most widely used desktop OS on the planet. On the desktop, it's better than OS X and it's better than Linux and if you disagree then you're obviously out of whack with the rest of the world's priorities because everybody uses Windows and they do so because Windows gives them what they want.
Yes, Windows 10 has some annoyances - just like every other OS in existence. Big deal. Windows has absolutely gotten better with each version. I've been using it since Windows 3 and honestly, saying that Windows hasn't gotten better with each version makes it seem like you have no clue at all what you're talking about.
Also, to the people complaining that you can't turn things off: You've been misinformed. You can turn off every single item that has been discussed and you can do it without "booting into safe-mode to delete an exe" for instance - http://www.tenforums.com/tutorials/3569-windows-defender-rea...
Technically they usually are, but then management starts making decisions about what is best. Not what is best for the user, what is best for Microsoft. If they just focused on the users, it would all work itself out. People would want to upgrade. Instead we get to login to our local machine with a Microsoft account, data tracking, etc. These are all things good for Microsoft.